Skip to content
Tag

Assault

Page 1 of 3 · 12 articles

Apartment complex walkway at dusk with a broken pedestrian gate, overgrown hedge, and dim stairwell lighting

Assaulted at a DFW Apartment Complex? When Texas Landlords Are Liable for Negligent Security

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: In Texas, an apartment owner can be held liable when a tenant or guest is assaulted, robbed, or otherwise hurt by a criminal on the property, but only in limited situations. Generally, the owner must have known or had reason to know of an unreasonable and foreseeable risk of that kind of crime, usually shown by similar prior crimes on or near the property, and must have failed to take reasonable steps to reduce it. Separately, the Texas Property Code requires landlords to provide specific locks and security devices and to rekey units between tenants. These claims are generally subject to a two-year deadline to file suit.

Apartment complex walkway at dusk with a broken pedestrian gate, overgrown hedge, and dim stairwell lighting

Being attacked where you live is frightening, and it is natural to ask whether the property should have done more. Broken gates, dark parking lots, missing deadbolts, and repeated break-ins that management ignored can all be part of a negligent security claim. Texas law, however, sets demanding rules for these cases, and the details matter.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth personal injury lawyers represent injured people and families throughout Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains how negligent security claims work in Texas, what the Texas Supreme Court requires, and what evidence tends to matter most.

Key Takeaways

  • The general rule favors property owners. The Texas Supreme Court has said that "generally, a premises owner has no duty to protect invitees from criminal acts by third parties," with an exception when the owner "knows or has reason to know of a risk of harm to invitees that is unreasonable and foreseeable" (Del Lago Partners v. Smith, Tex. 2010).
  • Prior crimes usually drive foreseeability. Courts weigh five Timberwalk factors: proximity, recency, frequency, similarity, and publicity of prior crimes (Timberwalk Apartments v. Cain, Tex. 1998).
  • Foreseeable is not enough by itself. In a 2017 case involving a shooting in an apartment visitor lot, the Texas Supreme Court held that a risk must be "both foreseeable and unreasonable," which also weighs the burden of preventing it (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie).
  • Texas law requires specific security devices. Without a tenant having to ask, a rental dwelling must have window latches, a doorknob lock or keyed dead bolt, sliding door pin locks and bars or handle latches, and a keyless bolting device and door viewer on each exterior door (Tex. Prop. Code §92.153).
  • Locks must be rekeyed between tenants. Landlords must rekey key, card, or combination devices within seven days after each tenant turnover (Tex. Prop. Code §92.156).
  • The criminal's share of fault counts. A defendant can ask the jury to assign responsibility to the attacker, even an unknown "John Doe," which can reduce what the property owner pays (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33).
  • Two years is the usual deadline. Personal injury suits generally must be filed "not later than two years after the day the cause of action accrues" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §16.003).

What Is a Negligent Security Claim in Texas?

A negligent security claim is a type of premises liability case. The injured person argues that the owner or manager of a property failed to use reasonable care to protect people on the property from a foreseeable crime, and that this failure was a cause of the injury.

These claims often arise from:

  • Assaults or robberies in apartment parking lots, breezeways, stairwells, and laundry rooms
  • Break-ins and home invasions where locks were missing, broken, or never rekeyed
  • Attacks through broken or propped-open access gates
  • Shootings or assaults at complexes with a known history of similar violence
  • Assaults in hotels, parking garages, bars, and retail centers

The person who committed the crime is always responsible for it. A negligent security claim asks a different question: whether the property owner also carries part of the responsibility because it ignored a risk it knew about or should have known about.

When Is a Texas Apartment Owner Responsible for a Crime on the Property?

Texas courts start from the rule that a property owner is generally not responsible for the criminal acts of others. Liability turns on whether the owner owed a legal duty in the situation, and that depends heavily on foreseeability.

The Timberwalk foreseeability factors

In Timberwalk Apartments, Partners, Inc. v. Cain, a Texas Supreme Court case involving the sexual assault of an apartment tenant, the court explained that "foreseeability of an unreasonable risk of criminal conduct is a prerequisite to imposing a duty of care" on someone who owns or controls premises (Timberwalk). Courts consider "whether any criminal conduct previously occurred on or near the property, how recently it occurred, how often it occurred, how similar the conduct was to the conduct on the property, and what publicity was given the occurrences."

Factor What courts look at Examples of helpful evidence
Proximity Crimes on the property or in its immediate vicinity Police reports for the complex address and adjacent properties
Recency How recently prior crimes happened Incidents in the months before the attack
Frequency How often crimes occurred A pattern of repeated incidents in a short period
Similarity Whether prior crimes put the owner on notice of the specific danger Prior assaults, robberies, or break-ins, not just minor property crimes
Publicity Whether the owner knew or should have known Tenant complaints, incident reports, emails to management, news coverage

The court added that these factors "must be considered together." It also explained that prior crimes do not need to be identical: a string of assaults and robberies can make other violent crimes foreseeable, while unreported crimes that no one knew about are not evidence of foreseeability. Courts have also said that property owners have no duty to regularly check criminal records for their area, though widely publicized crimes can show knowledge (Jai Jalaram v. LeRibeus, Tex. App. 2006).

The risk must also be unreasonable

In UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie (2017), a visitor was robbed and shot in the knee in the public visitor parking lot of a Texas apartment complex. The Texas Supreme Court reversed a judgment for the visitor and explained: "We have consistently said that a risk must be both foreseeable and unreasonable to impose a duty on a property owner" (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie). Because the visitor offered no evidence about the burden of preventing or reducing the risk, the court rendered judgment for the complex.

The practical lesson is that a strong case needs two kinds of proof: evidence that the crime was foreseeable, and evidence that reasonable, available steps (such as repairing a gate, fixing lighting, or responding to repeated reports) could have reduced the risk.

When danger is imminent

Foreseeability can also come from what is happening in the moment. In Del Lago Partners v. Smith, the court upheld a verdict against a resort bar that "had actual and direct knowledge that a violent brawl was imminent between drunk, belligerent patrons and had ample time and means to defuse the situation" (Del Lago). The court stressed that the duty "arose not because of prior similar criminal conduct but because it was aware of an unreasonable risk of harm at the bar that very night," and that it was not announcing a general rule.

What Security Devices Must Texas Landlords Provide?

Separate from the general negligence rules, Subchapter D of Chapter 92 of the Texas Property Code sets specific security device requirements for residential rentals (Tex. Prop. Code ch. 92).

Under §92.153, unless an exception applies, and without a tenant having to ask, a dwelling must have:

  1. A window latch on each exterior window
  2. A doorknob lock or keyed dead bolt on each exterior door
  3. A sliding door pin lock on each exterior sliding glass door
  4. A sliding door handle latch or security bar on each exterior sliding glass door
  5. A keyless bolting device and a door viewer on each exterior door

Other key rules include:

  • Rekeying: Under §92.156(a), security devices operated by a key, card, or combination must be rekeyed at the landlord's expense "not later than the seventh day after each tenant turnover date."
  • Repairs: Under §92.158, a landlord must repair or replace a security device on request or notice that it is inoperable.
  • Timing: Under §92.161, repair and rekeying requests are presumed due within seven days, but within 72 hours if the tenant told the landlord about an unauthorized entry in the unit, an attempted or actual entry in another unit in the past two months, or a crime of personal violence at the complex in the past two months.

If a landlord does not comply with §92.153 or §92.156(a), §92.164 lets a tenant seek remedies including actual damages. The statute's attorney's fee provisions do not apply in suits for personal injuries or wrongful death. In practice, a missing or broken required lock is often powerful evidence in a broader negligence claim, especially when the tenant reported it in writing.

How Does the Attacker's Fault Affect the Claim?

Texas uses proportionate responsibility. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, the jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to each claimant, defendant, settling person, and designated "responsible third party" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §33.003).

That matters in negligent security cases because:

  • The attacker can be on the verdict form. Even if the attacker was never identified, §33.004(j) allows a defendant to designate an unknown person as a responsible third party if it timely pleads facts showing a reasonable probability that the person's act was criminal.
  • A defendant generally pays only its own share. Under §33.013(a), a liable defendant is generally responsible for its own percentage, unless its share is greater than 50 percent, in which case it is jointly and severally liable under §33.013(b)(1).
  • The injured person's own fault can reduce or bar recovery. Under §33.001, a claimant cannot recover if his or her percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. Our guide to how fault works in Texas personal injury cases explains these rules in more detail.

What Evidence Matters in a DFW Negligent Security Case?

Because these cases turn on what the owner knew before the attack, evidence often disappears quickly. Useful evidence can include:

  • Police call and incident records for the complex and nearby properties, often obtained through public information requests to the local police department
  • Management records such as incident reports, tenant complaints, work orders for gates, lights, and locks, and emails or portal messages
  • Your lease and any lease addenda, including security device and crime-related notices
  • Photos and video of broken gates, burned-out lights, damaged locks, or overgrown landscaping, taken as soon as possible
  • Surveillance video, which many properties record over within days or weeks
  • Security contracts and patrol logs, if the property used a guard or courtesy officer service
  • Witness information from neighbors who reported prior problems

A prompt written request to preserve video and records can be important. Insurance carriers for apartment owners often investigate quickly; our article on insurance adjuster tactics in Fort Worth explains what to watch for.

What Should You Do After Being Assaulted at an Apartment Complex?

  1. Get to safety and call 911. A police report documents the crime and its location.
  2. Get medical care right away, and keep records of every visit. Injuries such as head trauma and emotional harm may not be fully apparent at first.
  3. Report the incident to management in writing and keep a copy.
  4. Photograph the scene, including gates, lighting, locks, and doors, before repairs are made.
  5. Write down what you remember and the names of anyone who saw what happened or reported earlier problems.
  6. Avoid giving recorded statements to the property's insurer before getting legal advice, and be careful about what you post on social media.
  7. Talk with a lawyer early, so evidence can be requested before it is lost and the two-year filing deadline is protected.

If a loved one was killed in a crime at a property, the family may have a wrongful death claim. See our wrongful death practice page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my apartment complex if I was robbed in the parking lot?

Possibly. You would generally need to show that the complex knew or should have known of an unreasonable and foreseeable risk of that kind of crime, often through similar prior crimes on or near the property, and that it failed to take reasonable steps that would have reduced the risk. Each case depends on its facts.

Does a single prior crime make an attack foreseeable?

Usually not by itself. The Texas Supreme Court has said that "the complete absence of previous crimes, or the occurrence of a few crimes over an extended time period, negates the foreseeability element," while a significant number of crimes in a short time strengthens it (Timberwalk). The more similar the prior crimes, the fewer may be needed.

Is a broken gate or burned-out light enough to win a case?

Not on its own. A broken gate or dark area can be important evidence that reasonable precautions were not taken, but Texas courts also require proof that the crime was foreseeable and that the risk was unreasonable. Written reports to management about the problem can strengthen the claim.

Can guests and visitors bring negligent security claims?

Yes, guests and other invitees can bring these claims. The visitor in Petrie was in a complex's visitor lot. The same foreseeability and unreasonableness rules apply.

Does it matter that the attacker was never caught?

A claim can proceed even if the attacker is unknown. The defendant may ask to designate the unknown person as a responsible third party under §33.004(j), and the jury may then assign that person a percentage of responsibility.

How long do I have to file a negligent security lawsuit in Texas?

Generally two years from the date of the injury under §16.003. Exceptions can apply, such as for minors, so it is best to get advice promptly.

Do these rules apply to hotels, bars, and stores too?

Yes. The Timberwalk foreseeability factors are applied to many kinds of commercial property, and Del Lago involved a resort bar. Our article on parking lot and sidewalk injuries in Texas covers other premises claims.

Talk to a Fort Worth Premises Liability Lawyer

Negligent security cases are fact-intensive and often hard-fought. Early investigation into prior crimes, complaints, and repairs can make a significant difference.

Call HLAW at (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation about an injury at a Dallas-Fort Worth apartment complex or other property.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article
Man seen from behind sitting on a curb at dawn with a duffel bag and house keys, looking across the street at a suburban home he has been ordered to stay away from

Arrested for Family Violence in Fort Worth or Dallas? Emergency Protective Orders, Bond Conditions, and the First Days After Arrest

By Luke A. Williams · Criminal Defense

Short answer: After an arrest for family violence assault in Texas, a magistrate can, and in cases involving serious bodily injury or a deadly weapon must, issue a magistrate's order for emergency protection (often called an EPO). An EPO can bar you from going home, contacting the alleged victim, or possessing a firearm for 61 to 91 days, or up to 121 days if a deadly weapon is alleged. Violating it is a separate crime, even if the alleged victim invites you back. The alleged victim also can't simply "drop the charges"; in Tarrant County, the District Attorney's Office decides whether the case goes forward.

Man seen from behind sitting on a curb at dawn with a duffel bag and house keys, looking across the street at a suburban home he has been ordered to stay away from

A family violence arrest moves fast. One night there is an argument and a 911 call; by the next morning, you may be released from the Tarrant County or Dallas County jail with a bond, a list of conditions, and an order that says you can't go back to your own house. What you do in those first days often shapes how the case ends.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth criminal defense lawyers defend family violence cases across Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide covers what happens right after an arrest: the jail hold, the emergency protective order, the bond conditions, and the mistakes that turn one charge into two. For a broader overview of these cases, see our domestic violence defense page.

Key Takeaways

  • There may be a hold even after bond is posted. In some family violence arrests, the jail can hold you four hours after bond is posted, and a magistrate can extend that for up to 48 hours (Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 17.291).
  • An EPO can be issued at your first appearance. It is mandatory if the arrest involves serious bodily injury or a deadly weapon (art. 17.292(b)).
  • EPOs last longer than many people expect. Most remain in effect 61 to 91 days; deadly-weapon EPOs remain in effect 91 to 121 days (art. 17.292(j)).
  • The protected person can't waive it. The order itself states that no one, including the protected person, can give permission to violate it (art. 17.292(g)).
  • A violation is a new charge. Violating an EPO or a family violence bond condition is a Class A misdemeanor, and it can become a felony (Tex. Penal Code §25.07).
  • Guns must go. Possessing a firearm while subject to an EPO is a separate Class A misdemeanor for anyone other than an actively employed, full-time peace officer (Penal Code §46.04(c)).

What Happens at the Jail After a Family Violence Arrest?

Most family violence arrests in DFW are warrantless; officers respond to a call and make an arrest at the scene. You'll be booked into a city jail or the county jail and brought before a magistrate, who reads your rights, sets bond, and decides whether to issue an emergency protective order and what conditions to attach to your bond.

The four-hour (and up to 48-hour) hold

Texas has a special rule for these cases. Under article 17.291, when a person is arrested without a warrant "in the prevention of family violence" and there is probable cause to believe the violence will continue if the person is released immediately, the arresting agency "shall hold the person for a period of four hours after bond has been posted." A magistrate can extend the hold for up to 48 more hours, but only in writing and only after concluding that the violence would continue. Holds longer than 24 hours also require prior family violence arrests or a prior deadly-weapon arrest within the last 10 years.

Families are often confused when a bond is paid and their loved one still isn't released. This hold is frequently the reason. Our guide to bail bonds after a Fort Worth arrest explains the general bond process.

Don't explain your side at the jail

Calls from the jail are recorded, and officers may ask what happened. Anything you say can be used to prove the State's case. The best practice is to politely decline to discuss the incident until you've talked with a lawyer. Our article Miranda or No Miranda, Do Not Make a Statement explains why.

What Is a Magistrate's Order for Emergency Protection?

An emergency protective order is a criminal-court order that a magistrate issues at your first appearance after an arrest for an offense involving family violence (and certain other offenses, such as stalking and sexual assault). Under article 17.292(a), the magistrate may issue one on the magistrate's own motion or at the request of the alleged victim, the victim's guardian, a peace officer, or the prosecutor. It is mandatory under article 17.292(b) if the arrest also involves serious bodily injury or the use or exhibition of a deadly weapon during an assault.

An EPO is not the same as a protective order issued by a family court under Chapter 85 of the Family Code. A family-court protective order requires a separate application and hearing and can last up to two years or longer. Our article on lifting a protective order in Fort Worth covers those civil orders.

What can an EPO prohibit?

Under article 17.292(c), the magistrate can prohibit you from:

  1. Committing family violence or an assault against the protected person.
  2. Communicating with the protected person or household members in a threatening or harassing manner, or passing a threat through someone else. If the magistrate finds good cause, it can prohibit any communication except through your attorney or a court-appointed person.
  3. Going to or near the protected person's residence, workplace, or business, or the residence, child care facility, or school of a protected child.
  4. Possessing a firearm (unless you are a full-time, sworn peace officer actively employed by a state agency or political subdivision).
  5. Tracking or monitoring the protected person's property or vehicle, including with a phone tracking app or a tracking device, or by physically following them.

The "residence" restriction is often the hardest. If you live with the alleged victim, an EPO can effectively remove you from your own home, even if you own it or your name is on the lease.

How long does an EPO last?

Under the current version of article 17.292(j), an EPO takes effect immediately and:

Type of EPO Duration
Discretionary EPO, or mandatory EPO based on serious bodily injury At least 61 days, up to the 91st day after issuance
Mandatory EPO based on a deadly weapon used or exhibited during an assault At least 91 days, up to the 121st day after issuance

Read the order itself for its exact expiration date. Many people assume an EPO lasts 30 days because older versions of the law and older online articles say so, and that mistake leads to violations.

Can an EPO be changed?

Yes, but only by the court, and only after notice and a hearing. Under article 17.292(j), the issuing court may modify all or part of the order if it finds that the original order is unworkable, that the change will not place the victim at greater risk, and that the change will not endanger anyone protected by the order. Common requests include arranging a supervised pickup of clothes, work tools, or medication, or allowing communication about children through a third party. Until a judge signs a modification, the original order controls.

What Bond Conditions Are Common in Family Violence Cases?

Separate from the EPO, the magistrate can attach conditions to your bond. Article 17.49 specifically authorizes, in family violence cases:

  • Orders to stay away from a residence, school, workplace, or other location the alleged victim frequents, as specifically described in the bond
  • GPS monitoring, usually at the defendant's expense (with a sliding scale for indigent defendants)
  • A victim notification device, if the alleged victim consents
  • Orders not to track or monitor the alleged victim's property or vehicle

Magistrates can also impose other reasonable conditions, such as no-contact orders, alcohol monitoring, or counseling. Bond conditions generally last until the case is resolved or the court changes them, so they can outlast the EPO. Breaking a safety-related bond condition in a family violence case is itself a crime under Penal Code §25.07, and it can also get your bond revoked.

What Happens If You Violate an EPO or Bond Condition?

Every Texas EPO must state, in bold or capital letters, that "no person, including a person who is protected by this order, may give permission to anyone to ignore or violate any provision of this order" (art. 17.292(g)). In other words, if your spouse or partner calls and says "come home, it's fine," going home can still be a crime.

Under Penal Code §25.07, knowingly or intentionally violating an EPO or family violence bond condition by committing family violence, making prohibited communications, going to a prohibited location, possessing a firearm, interfering with a protected person's pet, tampering with a GPS monitor, or tracking the protected person is:

  • A Class A misdemeanor (up to one year in jail and a $4,000 fine) in most cases
  • A state jail felony if you violate certain provisions while possessing a deadly weapon
  • A third-degree felony if the violation involves an assault or stalking, or if you have two or more prior convictions for violating a protective order

Two or more violations within 12 months can be charged as a separate third-degree felony under Penal Code §25.072. Texts, social media messages, and messages passed through friends or relatives can all count as communication if the order prohibits it.

What to do about firearms

Under Penal Code §46.04(c), a person subject to an EPO who possesses a firearm after receiving notice of the order and before it expires commits a Class A misdemeanor. If you own guns, talk to your lawyer immediately about lawfully transferring them to a third party for the life of the order. And if your guns are kept in the home you've been ordered to stay away from, don't go back to get them yourself. Our article on firearms and DWI under Texas law discusses related firearm-possession rules.

Can the Alleged Victim Drop Family Violence Charges?

No. In Texas, the State, not the alleged victim, decides whether to prosecute. The Tarrant County Criminal District Attorney's Office says it "makes the ultimate decision of whether or not to proceed with a case based on the evidence available," that it does not generate affidavits of non-prosecution, and that "signing an affidavit will not stop prosecution."

An alleged victim may still sign an affidavit of non-prosecution. Tarrant County's published affidavit form must be notarized, and the county recommends scheduling an appointment because a meeting with an assistant district attorney is required. The affidavit is one factor the prosecutor considers, not a dismissal.

Two cautions matter here. First, the defendant should never ask, pressure, or arrange for the alleged victim to sign an affidavit or skip court. Depending on the facts and the orders in place, that contact can violate an EPO or bond condition and can lead to separate charges. Second, prosecutors often proceed without the alleged victim's testimony by using 911 recordings, body-camera video, photographs, and medical records.

Why the Outcome Matters So Much

Family violence cases carry consequences that go beyond the sentence:

  • Enhancement. A prior family violence assault conviction can turn a later Class A assault against a family member, household member, or dating partner into a third-degree felony. So can an allegation of impeding breathing or circulation (choking), even without a prior conviction (Penal Code §22.01(b)(2)). Our Texas assault offenses overview covers the assault statute.
  • State firearm restrictions. A Class A family violence assault conviction bars firearm possession under Texas law until the fifth anniversary of release from confinement or community supervision (Penal Code §46.04(b)).
  • Federal firearm restrictions. A qualifying misdemeanor crime of domestic violence conviction generally triggers a federal ban on possessing firearms or ammunition, and there is no exception for police or military personnel (ATF).
  • Record sealing. Texas bars an order of nondisclosure for a family violence offense, or when the court makes an affirmative finding that the offense involved family violence (Tex. Gov't Code §411.074). Our page on expunction and nondisclosure explains the difference.

Because these consequences can follow a person for years, how the case is resolved (dismissal, reduction to a non-family-violence offense, deferred adjudication, or trial) deserves careful attention from the start.

What Should You Do in the First Few Days?

  1. Read every order you were given. Find the EPO's expiration date, the specific addresses you must stay away from, and whether all contact or only threatening contact is prohibited.
  2. Follow the order literally. No visits, texts, social media messages, or "messages through mom," even if the other person reaches out first.
  3. Arrange a lawful place to stay. Plan for at least two to three months.
  4. Transfer firearms lawfully. Work with your lawyer to document a transfer to a third party.
  5. Retrieve belongings the right way. Ask your lawyer about a police standby or a court-approved arrangement.
  6. Save evidence. Preserve texts, call logs, photos, and the names of witnesses. Don't delete anything.
  7. Hire a defense lawyer early. Early representation can matter for bond modifications, EPO hearings, evidence preservation, and early discussions with the prosecutor.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does an emergency protective order last in Texas?

Most EPOs remain in effect at least 61 days and up to the 91st day after issuance. If the EPO is based on a deadly weapon used or exhibited during an assault, it lasts at least 91 days and up to the 121st day (art. 17.292(j)). Always check the date written on your order.

Can I go home if my spouse says it's okay?

Not if the EPO or your bond conditions prohibit it. The order states that no one, including the protected person, can give permission to violate it (art. 17.292(g)). Only the court can change it.

Is an EPO the same as a protective order?

No. An EPO is issued by a magistrate in the criminal case at your first appearance. A protective order under Chapter 85 of the Family Code is a separate civil order that requires its own application and hearing, and it can last much longer.

Why wasn't my family member released after bond was posted?

In family violence arrests, the jail may hold a person four hours after bond is posted, and a magistrate can extend the hold for up to 48 hours in writing (art. 17.291).

Can I keep my guns while my case is pending?

Not while an EPO is in effect, unless you fall within the narrow peace-officer exception; possession is a Class A misdemeanor (Penal Code §46.04(c)). Bond conditions may also prohibit firearms.

Will an affidavit of non-prosecution get my case dismissed?

Not by itself. Tarrant County prosecutors say signing an affidavit "will not stop prosecution" and that the DA's office makes the final decision based on the evidence (Tarrant County CDA).

Talk to a Fort Worth Family Violence Defense Lawyer

The first days after a family violence arrest are when people make avoidable mistakes, like going home, sending one text, or keeping a gun in the closet, that create new charges. HLAW can review your EPO and bond conditions, request modifications when appropriate, and start building your defense right away. Call (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free, confidential consultation.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article
Silhouetted figures in a heated argument, representing the complexities of assault charges under Texas criminal law, with the Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC law firm logo.

Understanding Assault Under Texas Criminal Law

By Luke A. Williams · Criminal Defense

Silhouetted figures in a heated argument, representing the complexities of assault charges under Texas criminal law, with the Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC law firm logo.
An accusation of assault in Texas can have serious and life-altering consequences. Our latest blog post breaks down the different degrees of assault charges, potential penalties, and possible legal defenses. Learn more about protecting your rights.

When people hear the phrase “assault and battery,” they often envision two distinct criminal offenses: one encompassing threats of harm and the other involving actual physical violence. However, it's crucial to understand that under Texas law, the legal landscape is structured differently. The term “battery” is not used to define a separate criminal offense. Instead, both the act of threatening harm and/or the act of causing physical harm are typically consolidated under the broader legal definition of assault. This fundamental difference is key to comprehending how such charges are prosecuted in the state.

This post aims to provide a comprehensive breakdown of what constitutes assault under the Texas Penal Code, delve into the varying degrees of severity and their classifications, and outline the potential penalties that individuals accused of these offenses may face. We will also explore related offenses like aggravated assault and common legal defenses.

Defining Assault in Texas: A Three-Pronged Approach

The Texas Penal Code § 22.01 provides a specific and multifaceted definition of assault. A person commits assault if they engage in any of the following actions:

  • Causing Bodily Injury: Intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly causing bodily injury to another person. This includes a spouse, and the term "recklessly" implies a conscious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk that the injury will occur. Bodily injury itself is defined broadly as physical pain, illness, or any impairment of physical condition. This means even an act causing temporary pain, without visible marks, could qualify.
  • Threatening Imminent Bodily Injury: Intentionally or knowingly threatening another person (including a spouse) with imminent bodily injury. The key here is the "imminent" nature of the threat; it must be a threat of harm that is about to happen. The threat can be conveyed through words, gestures, or a combination of both.
  • Causing Offensive or Provocative Physical Contact: Intentionally or knowingly causing physical contact with another person when they know—or should reasonably believe—that the other person will regard the contact as offensive or provocative. This prong does not require any injury. Examples could include an unwanted touch, a shove that doesn't cause pain but is clearly offensive, or spitting on someone.

Because this statutory definition of assault encompasses both verbal or gestural threats (with no physical harm necessarily resulting) and actual physical contact that might or might not cause bodily injury, Texas law effectively subsumes what many other jurisdictions would categorize separately as “battery” into its singular assault statute.

Degrees of Assault and Their Corresponding Penalties: A Spectrum of Severity

Assault charges in Texas are not one-size-fits-all. The severity of the charge and the potential penalties depend heavily on the specific circumstances of the incident, the harm caused, the identity of the victim, and the defendant's prior criminal history.

  • A. Class C Misdemeanor Assault
    • What It Is: This is the lowest level of assault. It typically involves situations where an individual threatens someone with imminent bodily injury but does not actually cause any physical harm, or where they cause physical contact that is deemed offensive or provocative but does not result in bodily injury. Examples could include a verbal threat of immediate harm or an unwelcome, offensive touch.
    • Penalties: A Class C misdemeanor is punishable by a fine of up to $500. While there is no jail time associated with a Class C misdemeanor conviction itself, failure to pay the fine or adhere to court orders can lead to further legal complications.

  • B. Class A Misdemeanor Assault
    • What It Is: This is a more serious charge and is often filed when the assault results in actual bodily injury to another person, and the circumstances do not elevate it to a felony. As previously noted, bodily injury is defined as physical pain, illness, or any impairment of physical condition. This could range from a bruise or scratch to more significant, but not life-threatening, injuries.
    • Penalties: A Class A misdemeanor carries significantly steeper penalties, including potential confinement in county jail for up to one year and/or a fine of up to $4,000.

  • C. Enhanced Misdemeanors and Felony Assault: When Circumstances Escalate the Charge The gravity of an assault charge can be substantially increased, elevating it from a lower-level misdemeanor to a higher-level misdemeanor or even a felony, based on several critical factors. These factors often relate to the identity of the victim, the defendant's prior criminal record, or the specific nature and context of the incident.
    • Assault Against a Public Servant:
      • If the victim of the assault is a public servant (such as a police officer, firefighter, emergency medical services (EMS) personnel, correctional officer, or even a process server) who is lawfully discharging an official duty, and the defendant knows the person is a public servant, the charge can be enhanced. An assault that might otherwise be a Class A misdemeanor can become a third-degree felony if it results in bodily injury to a public servant.
      • Penalties for a third-degree felony include imprisonment for 2 to 10 years and a fine of up to $10,000.

    • Assault Involving Family Violence:
      • Texas law takes domestic violence very seriously. If an assault involves a family member, household member, or someone with whom the defendant has or had a dating relationship, the penalties can be enhanced, especially with prior convictions.
      • A first offense of assault causing bodily injury to a family member is typically a Class A misdemeanor. However, if the defendant has a previous conviction for an offense involving family violence (including assault against a family member, violation of a protective order, or stalking), a subsequent assault against a family member causing bodily injury can be charged as a third-degree felony.
      • Furthermore, if the assault involves impeding the normal breathing or circulation of the blood of a family member or household member by applying pressure to the throat or neck (strangulation or choking) or by blocking the nose or mouth (suffocation), this act itself can elevate the charge. Such an offense can be a third-degree felony, or even a second-degree felony if the defendant has a previous conviction for a similar offense.
      • Penalties for a second-degree felony range from 2 to 20 years in prison and a fine of up to $10,000.

    • Assault Against Elderly& or Disabled Individuals:
      • Assault committed against an elderly individual (defined as someone 65 years of age or older) or a disabled individual can also lead to enhanced charges. Depending on the severity of the injury and the defendant's intent, these offenses can be prosecuted as felonies, reflecting the state's interest in protecting vulnerable populations.

Aggravated Assault: A More Serious Offense

Distinct from simple assault, though closely related, is the offense of aggravated assault, as defined under Texas Penal Code § 22.02. This charge signifies a more severe form of assault. A person commits aggravated assault if, during the commission of an assault (as previously defined), they either:

  • Cause serious bodily injury to another person (including their spouse). Serious bodily injury means bodily injury that creates a substantial risk of death or that causes death, serious permanent disfigurement, or protracted loss or impairment of the function of any bodily member or organ.
  • Use or exhibit a deadly weapon during the commission of the assault. A deadly weapon can be a firearm or anything manifestly designed, made, or adapted for the purpose of inflicting death or serious bodily injury; or anything that in the manner of its use or intended use is capable of causing death or serious bodily injury.
  • Penalties for Aggravated Assault:
    • Generally, aggravated assault is classified as a second-degree felony. This carries a potential punishment of 2 to 20 years in prison and a fine of up to $10,000.

  • Enhanced Aggravated Assault Charges:
    • Similar to simple assault, aggravated assault charges can be further enhanced under specific circumstances. For instance, if the aggravated assault is committed against a public servant acting in their official capacity, or involves discharging a firearm from a motor vehicle towards a habitation, building, or vehicle and causing serious bodily injury, the charge can be elevated to a first-degree felony.
    • A first-degree felony is punishable by imprisonment for 5 to 99 years, or life, and a fine of up to $10,000.

Exploring Possible Legal Defenses in Assault Cases

Facing an assault charge does not automatically mean conviction. The Texas legal system provides for due process and various defenses that, if applicable to the facts of the case, could lead to charges being reduced or dismissed. Common defenses in assault cases include:

  • Self-Defense (Texas Penal Code Chapter 9): This is one of the most common defenses. A defendant may argue that their actions were justified because they reasonably believed that the force they used was immediately necessary to protect themselves from the other person's use or attempted use of unlawful force. The amount of force used in self-defense must be reasonable in relation to the perceived threat.
  • Defense of Others (Texas Penal Code Chapter 9): Similar to self-defense, a person is justified in using force to protect another individual if they reasonably believe the other person would be justified in using force to protect themselves, and the defendant reasonably believes their intervention is immediately necessary.
  • Lack of Intent (Mens Rea): For most assault charges, the prosecution must prove a culpable mental state (intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly). If the contact or threat was purely accidental, and the defendant did not possess the requisite intent to cause harm, threaten, or make offensive contact, this could be a defense. For example, if bodily injury occurred due to an unforeseeable accident rather than intentional or reckless conduct.
  • Mistaken Identity / Alibi: The defendant may argue they are not the person who committed the act in question or were wrongly identified by witnesses. An alibi defense would involve presenting evidence that the defendant was elsewhere when the alleged assault occurred.
  • Consent: While not applicable in many assault scenarios (one cannot generally consent to serious bodily injury), in limited circumstances involving offensive contact or minor bodily injury (e.g., a contact sport), consent might be a factor.

It is absolutely critical to understand that the viability and success of these defenses are highly dependent on the specific, unique facts and circumstances of each individual case. Gathering evidence, witness testimony, and understanding the nuances of Texas self-defense laws (including the Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground principles, where applicable) are vital. Therefore, consulting with an experienced criminal defense attorney is paramount to thoroughly investigate the case, identify all possible defenses, and develop an effective and tailored defense strategy.

Consequences Beyond Criminal Penalties: The Ripple Effect of an Assault Conviction

A conviction for assault in Texas can have profound and lasting repercussions that extend far beyond court-imposed fines and potential imprisonment. These collateral consequences can significantly impact a person’s future:

  • Permanent Criminal Record: An assault conviction, particularly a felony, creates a permanent criminal record that is accessible through background checks. This can severely limit opportunities for employment (especially in certain professions like teaching, healthcare, or law enforcement), housing (as landlords often run checks), and higher education.
  • Issuance of Protective Orders: Victims of assault, especially in family violence cases, may seek and obtain protective orders (also known as restraining orders) against the defendant. These orders can legally prohibit the defendant from contacting the victim, going near their residence or workplace, or possessing a firearm, often for extended periods (e.g., two years, or sometimes longer). Violating a protective order is a separate criminal offense.
  • Loss of Civil Rights: Certain convictions, predominantly felonies, can lead to the loss or restriction of fundamental civil rights. This includes the right to vote (until the sentence, including parole or probation, is fully discharged) and the right to possess firearms under both federal and state law.
  • Immigration Consequences: For non-U.S. citizens, an assault conviction can have severe immigration consequences, potentially leading to deportation, denial of naturalization, or inability to re-enter the United States.
  • Professional Licensing Issues: Many professions require state licenses (e.g., doctors, nurses, lawyers, teachers, real estate agents). An assault conviction can jeopardize an existing license or prevent an individual from obtaining one.
  • Social Stigma: The social stigma associated with an assault conviction can affect personal relationships and standing in the community.

Conclusion: Navigating Assault Charges in Texas Requires Expertise

In summary, under Texas law, the traditional concept of “battery” is effectively integrated within the broader offense of “assault”. This legal framework makes it essential for anyone facing such allegations to understand precisely how Texas law defines and penalizes a wide array of threatening or harmful behaviors.

Whether an assault charge is classified as a misdemeanor or a felony, it invariably carries the potential for serious penalties, including substantial fines, incarceration (in county jail or state prison), and a host of long-term collateral consequences that can shape an individual's future. Given the complexities of the law, the nuances of evidence, and the severity of potential outcomes, facing an assault charge alone is a daunting prospect.

Facing assault charges in Texas can be overwhelming, with serious consequences that can impact your life for years to come. Don't navigate this complex legal challenge alone. If you or someone you know is confronting assault charges, the time to act is now. It is absolutely imperative to secure the counsel of a qualified and experienced criminal defense attorney immediately.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our knowledgeable attorneys are ready to:

  • Meticulously analyze the specific details of your case.
  • Clearly explain your rights and the charges you face.
  • Thoroughly explore all available defenses.
  • Skillfully navigate the intricate Texas legal system on your behalf.
  • Advocate zealously to protect your rights and fight for the best possible outcome.

Your future is too important to leave to chance. Contact Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW) today for a confidential consultation. Let our experience work for you.

Read full article
Assault as Lesser Included

Assault By Contact NOT an LIO of Assault Bodily Injury

By Brandon Barnett · Assault

Is the Class C charge of Assault (Offensive Contact) a lesser-included offense of the Class A charge of Assault (Bodily Injury)?

In short, the answer is most likely No.

Assault as Lesser IncludedAn offensive-contact assault not a lesser-included offense of a bodily-injury assault because the offenses have different elements.

The Court of Criminal Appeals, whose opinions are controlling in Texas, held that an offensive-contact assault is not a lesser-included offense (“LIO”) of a bodily-injury assault because what the state was required to prove for one offense differed from what the state had to prove for the other (McKithan v. State, 324 S.W.3d 582, 583, 591 (Tex. Crim. App. 2010)). For a Class A misdemeanor bodily-injury assault, the state must prove that bodily injury (or pain) occurred; the statute does not require the state to prove that the contact was offensive or provocative (Tex. Penal Code § 22.01(a)(1), (a)(3)). An offense is not an LIO if the state must prove different elements for each offense (McKithan, 324 S.W.3d at 583, 591). It is not enough that “proof of the charged [] offense may also” show the other offense; the State must be “required to prove these offenses in establishing the charged offenses” (Id. at 593).

Granted, seven years before McKithan, the Court of Criminal Appeals stated that an offensive-contact assault is an LIO “of (a)(1), because [it is] proved by less than all the facts required to prove (a)(1), specifically, physical injury” (Reed v. State, 117 S.W.3d 260, 267 (Tex. Crim. App. 2003)). However, the Court of Criminal Appeals seemed to move away from this categorical view in McKithan.

Additionally, the appeals court presiding over cases in Tarrant County, the Second Court of Appeals, held that an offensive-contact assault “is not, under the circumstances of this case, a lesser-included offense of assault causing bodily injury” (Welsh v. State, 2009 Tex. App. LEXIS 3592, *4-5 (Tex. App—Fort Worth May 21, 2009)). Other courts echo this sentiment. For example, in Norman v. State, the appeals court held that the trial court did not make a mistake when it refused to instruct the jury on offensive-contact assaults as a LIO of bodily-injury assaults because offensive-contact assaults have a unique element (2019 Tex. App. LEXIS 6690, *16-17 (Tex. App—Amarillo August 1, 2019). And one Houston court stated that “[b]ecause offensive-contact assault is not within the proof necessary to establish bodily-injury assault, it is not a lesser-included offense” (Washington v. State, 2019 Tex. App. LEXIS 5409, *12 (Tex. App—Houston June 27, 2019)).

Thus, offensive-contact assaults are not considered LIOs of assaults causing bodily. An assault under § 22.01(a)(3) has elements unique to it, so one cannot prove an assault under § 22.01(a)(1) by establishing the elements of assault under § 22.01(a)(3).

Read full article
Confrontation Clause violation when victim does not testify? McDowell v. State (2018)

Confrontation Clause Violation When Accuser Does Not Appear at Trial

By Brandon Barnett · Confrontation Clause

Tarrant County Trial Court Admits Testimony in Violation of the Confrontation Clause

The Second Court of Appeals recently released a memorandum opinion, which reversed a defendant’s conviction due to a confrontation clause violation. The issue was whether the trial court (Criminal District Court Number 1, Tarrant County) erred in allowing an officer to testify about certain statements the alleged victim made regarding a prior assault allegation.

McDowell v. State—2nd Court of Appeals (2018)

The Facts—Defendant Was Convicted for Felony Domestic Violence

On August 21, 2016, officers were alerted to a domestic disturbance in progress. When officers arrived at the scene they made contact with the victim and the victim’s friend who had reported the disturbance. While talking with the two females, officers noticed multiple bruises on the victim and learned that the suspect (i.e. Defendant), who had allegedly assaulted the victim, was still inside the home. Officers subsequently entered the residence and arrested Defendant.

At trial, dash-cam video showing the accusations made by the two females was admitted. In addition, one of the officers testified to additional statements made by the victim suggesting that the defendant had a history of violence. These additional statements, however, were not included in the dash cam video. Defendant objected to these statements under Crawford because the victim did not appear at trial. Nonetheless, the trial court allowed the out-of-court statements to be admitted over objection.

In addition to the officer’s testimony regarding the hearsay statements, the jury heard from two other witnesses about the cycle of domestic violence. The State then referenced this testimony in relation to Defendant’s history of domestic violence during closing arguments. As a result, Defendant was convicted. Defendant later appealed his conviction arguing that the trial court erred when it allowed the officer to testify to the victim’s statements in violation of the confrontation clause of the 6th Amendment.

Court of Appeals Reverses and Remands Case—Holding the Trial Court Erred in Admitting the Officer’s Testimony

Generally, the Confrontation Clause bars admission of testimonial statements of a witness who does not appear at trial. In determining whether certain statements were testimonial in nature, “the Court looks to see whether circumstances were present at the time the statements were made that would indicate the existence of an ongoing emergency.” If such circumstances existed, the statements are admissible.

Here, the victim did not appear at trial. As such, the Court of Appeals attempted to analyze whether the victim’s statements were testimonial in nature by determining whether they were made during the ongoing emergency. However, the Court was unable to do so because there was no evidence from the State regarding when these statements were made. The Court concluded that without knowing the timing at which the statements were made, there was no way to determine the existence of an ongoing emergency. The Court explained that once there is an objection to the admission of evidence on confrontation grounds the burden shifts to the State. Here, the State was silent in regard to the confrontation objection. And, without the State providing more evidence, the Court could not conclude that the statements were nontestimonial. Accordingly, the Court held that the trial court erred in admitting the statements.

The Court then conducted a harm analysis to determine whether the error impacted the jury’s verdict, which would require a reversal. In making its determination, the Court noted that the majority of the officer’s testimony was based on the inadmissible statements. These statements portrayed a history of violence rather than just one instance. Further, the other witnesses’ testimony hinged on these inadmissible statements. Thus, because the inadmissible statements were a crucial part in establishing the elements of the offense, the Court could not say beyond a reasonable doubt that the trial court’s error did not contribute to Defendant’s conviction and, therefore, a reversal was required.

Read full article

Speak with a Fort Worth attorney

Call (817) 993-9249 or send us a message to discuss your case.