Skip to content
Tag

How Expert Witnesses Strengthen Your Texas Personal Injury Case

Page 1 of 15 · 72 articles

Empty jury box in a wood-paneled Texas courtroom with a male trial attorney at the lectern, illustrating punitive damages in Texas

Punitive Damages in Texas: Gross Negligence, the Damages Cap, and the Drunk-Driver Exception

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: Texas law calls punitive damages "exemplary damages," and they are awarded to punish a defendant, not to compensate the injured person. To recover them, an injured person must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the harm resulted from fraud, malice, or gross negligence, and the jury must be unanimous on both liability and amount. Most awards are capped at the greater of $200,000 or two times economic damages plus up to $750,000 in noneconomic damages, but the cap does not apply when the claim is based on felony conduct such as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter by a drunk driver.

Empty jury box in a wood-paneled Texas courtroom with a male trial attorney at the lectern, illustrating punitive damages in Texas

Most personal injury cases are about making the injured person whole: medical bills, lost wages, pain, and the other losses a crash or fall causes. Some cases involve conduct so dangerous that Texas allows a jury to go further and punish the wrongdoer. A driver who gets behind the wheel after a night of heavy drinking, or a company that knowingly sends workers into an extreme hazard, may face that kind of claim.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth personal injury lawyers represent injured people and families in Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains when punitive damages are available in Texas, what "gross negligence" actually means, how the statutory cap works, and why drunk-driving cases are treated differently.

Key Takeaways

  • Punishment, not compensation. Texas defines exemplary damages as damages "awarded as a penalty or by way of punishment but not for compensatory purposes," and the term includes punitive damages (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.001).
  • Higher proof is required. The injured person must prove fraud, malice, or gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence, and ordinary negligence is not enough (§ 41.003).
  • The jury must be unanimous. Exemplary damages may be awarded only if the jury is unanimous on both liability for and the amount of those damages (§ 41.003(d)).
  • Most awards are capped. The cap is the greater of $200,000 or two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000 (§ 41.008(b)).
  • Drunk drivers are an exception. The cap does not apply to claims based on intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter, and for those two offenses the statute does not require proof that the conduct was knowing or intentional (§ 41.008(c)).
  • Companies are judged by their own conduct. A corporation is liable for punitive damages only when the gross negligence is attributable to the corporation itself (Mobil Oil Corp. v. Ellender, Tex. 1998).

What Are Punitive (Exemplary) Damages in Texas?

Compensatory damages pay for the harm a person suffered. Texas splits them into two groups. Economic damages cover measurable financial losses such as medical expenses and lost earnings. Noneconomic damages cover losses like physical pain, mental anguish, disfigurement, and impairment. Our guide to what a personal injury case is worth in Texas walks through those categories in detail.

Exemplary damages are different. Chapter 41 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code states that exemplary damages "are neither economic nor noneconomic damages" (§ 41.001). They exist to punish conduct and to deter others from doing the same thing. That purpose explains why the law makes them harder to get than ordinary damages and why a jury can consider facts, like a defendant's net worth, that would not matter in a normal damages calculation.

Two threshold rules apply before any punitive award can stand. First, exemplary damages may be awarded only if damages other than nominal damages are awarded (§ 41.004(a)). In plain terms, the injured person must first prove real harm. Second, a claimant who elects to have a recovery multiplied under another statute cannot also collect exemplary damages for the same harm (§ 41.004(b)).

What Does a Texas Injury Victim Have to Prove to Get Punitive Damages?

Under § 41.003(a), exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the harm resulted from one of three things:

  1. Fraud, which the statute defines as fraud other than constructive fraud.
  2. Malice, meaning "a specific intent by the defendant to cause substantial injury or harm to the claimant."
  3. Gross negligence, which is the basis for most punitive damages claims in car wreck, trucking, workplace, and premises cases.

The burden is demanding. "Clear and convincing" means proof that "will produce in the mind of the trier of fact a firm belief or conviction as to the truth of the allegations sought to be established" (§ 41.001(2)). The statute also says this burden "may not be shifted to the defendant or satisfied by evidence of ordinary negligence, bad faith, or a deceptive trade practice" (§ 41.003(b)).

Proving that a driver ran a red light or was looking at a phone usually establishes ordinary negligence. Proving gross negligence requires evidence about what the defendant knew and chose to do anyway.

What Is Gross Negligence Under Texas Law?

Texas defines gross negligence as an act or omission that has two parts (§ 41.001(11)):

  • An objective part. Viewed objectively from the defendant's standpoint at the time, the conduct "involves an extreme degree of risk, considering the probability and magnitude of the potential harm to others."
  • A subjective part. The defendant "has actual, subjective awareness of the risk involved, but nevertheless proceeds with conscious indifference to the rights, safety, or welfare of others."

The Supreme Court of Texas has explained both parts. In Medina v. Zuniga, the court said an extreme risk is "not a remote possibility of injury or even a high probability of minor harm, but rather the likelihood of serious injury to the plaintiff" (Medina v. Zuniga, Tex. 2019). For the subjective part, the court said "the plaintiff must show that the defendant knew about the peril, but his acts or omissions demonstrate that he did not care." In that case, the court held there was no evidence supporting the objective component and rendered judgment that the plaintiff take nothing on her gross negligence claim.

That outcome shows how carefully Texas courts review these findings. A serious injury alone does not prove gross negligence. The question is whether the conduct itself created a likelihood of serious harm and whether the defendant actually knew it.

Common examples of conduct that may support a gross negligence claim

Every case depends on its facts, but gross negligence claims in Dallas-Fort Worth injury cases often involve evidence like:

  • A driver who chose to drive while heavily intoxicated
  • A trucking company that kept a driver on the road after learning of repeated safety violations
  • An employer that knew about a specific, serious hazard and sent workers into it anyway
  • A property owner who knew about a dangerous condition that had already injured people and did nothing

How Much Can a Jury Award? The Texas Punitive Damages Cap

Texas caps most exemplary damages awards. Under § 41.008(b), exemplary damages awarded against a defendant may not exceed the greater of:

  • Option 1: two times the amount of economic damages, plus an amount equal to any noneconomic damages found by the jury, not to exceed $750,000; or
  • Option 2: $200,000.

To make that calculation possible, the jury must determine economic damages separately from other compensatory damages (§ 41.008(a)).

Example Economic damages Noneconomic damages Option 1 (2x economic + noneconomic up to $750,000) Maximum exemplary award
Smaller case $20,000 $30,000 $70,000 $200,000 (the floor applies)
Moderate case $100,000 $500,000 $700,000 $700,000
Large case $724,456.60 $900,000 $1,448,913.20 + $750,000 $2,198,913.20

The third row is not hypothetical. In a Denton County wrongful death case involving a worker killed at a landfill, a jury awarded $724,456.60 in economic damages, $900,000 in noneconomic damages, and $10,000,000 in exemplary damages. The trial court applied the cap and entered judgment for $2,198,913.20 (Waste Management of Texas, Inc. v. Dodd, Tex. App.-Fort Worth 2025). As discussed below, the Fort Worth Court of Appeals later reversed the gross negligence finding entirely.

Why Are Drunk-Driving Crashes Treated Differently?

Section 41.008(c) lists felonies that remove the cap. Most of them, such as murder, aggravated assault, and certain theft offenses, lift the cap only "if the conduct was committed knowingly or intentionally." Two offenses on the list are expressly excluded from that knowing-or-intentional requirement: Penal Code § 49.07 (intoxication assault) and § 49.08 (intoxication manslaughter) (§ 41.008(c)).

That matters in Dallas-Fort Worth, where intoxicated-driver crashes on I-30, I-35W, Loop 820, and US-75 cause catastrophic injuries every year. When the claim against a drunk driver is based on conduct described as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter, the statutory cap on exemplary damages does not apply. The injured person still has to meet the clear and convincing standard and win a unanimous jury, but the jury is not limited by the § 41.008(b) formula.

A drunk-driving case can also involve other defendants. If a bar or restaurant served an obviously intoxicated customer who then caused a crash, the injured person may have a separate claim against the business. Our guide to Texas dram shop laws and drunk driving explains how those claims work.

Can You Get Punitive Damages From a Trucking Company or Employer?

Yes, but the rules are stricter. In Mobil Oil Corp. v. Ellender, the Supreme Court of Texas held that "a corporation may be liable in punitive damages for gross negligence only if the corporation itself commits gross negligence" (Mobil Oil Corp. v. Ellender, Tex. 1998). Because a company acts only through people, Texas courts look at whether:

  • The company authorized or ratified an agent's gross negligence
  • The company was grossly negligent in hiring an unfit agent
  • The gross negligence was committed by a "vice principal," such as a corporate officer, a person with authority to hire, direct, and fire employees, or a manager in charge of a department or division

The Dodd case shows how this plays out. The Fort Worth Court of Appeals concluded "that the record lacks evidence to show that Dodd's death was caused by grossly negligent acts or omissions attributable to Waste Management" and rendered judgment that the widow take nothing on her gross negligence claim (Waste Management of Texas, Inc. v. Dodd). The court found the evidence did not show that the supervisor involved qualified as a manager under the jury charge.

For injured people, the lesson is practical. A punitive damages claim against a company depends on evidence about who knew what inside the company: safety records, internal emails, prior incidents, training files, and testimony from decision-makers. That evidence must be identified and preserved early.

Are Punitive Damages Available in a Texas Wrongful Death Case?

Yes. The Texas Wrongful Death Act provides that when "the death is caused by the wilful act or omission or gross negligence of the defendant, exemplary as well as actual damages may be recovered" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 71.009). The same Chapter 41 standards apply, including the clear and convincing burden, jury unanimity, and the cap unless an exception applies. Our page on wrongful death claims explains who can bring these cases and what damages are available.

Families may also have related claims. A spouse or child of a person who survives with serious, permanent injuries may have a loss of consortium claim, which is a compensatory claim separate from any punitive award.

How Does a Jury Decide the Amount of Punitive Damages?

The trial can be split into two phases

On a defendant's motion, the court must hold a bifurcated trial (§ 41.009). In the first phase, the jury decides liability for compensatory and exemplary damages and the amount of compensatory damages. Only if exemplary liability is established does the jury move to a second phase to decide the amount of exemplary damages. This keeps evidence like a defendant's net worth out of the first phase.

The jury considers specific factors

Under § 41.011(a), the jury must consider evidence, if any, relating to:

  • The nature of the wrong
  • The character of the conduct involved
  • The degree of culpability of the wrongdoer
  • The situation and sensibilities of the parties concerned
  • The extent to which the conduct offends a public sense of justice and propriety
  • The net worth of the defendant

Subject to the cap, whether to award exemplary damages and how much is within the jury's discretion (§ 41.010(b)).

Appellate courts must explain their review

When a Texas court of appeals reviews a punitive damages finding or amount, it must state its reasons in a written opinion that addresses the evidence "with specificity" (§ 41.013(a)). That requirement is one reason these awards receive close attention after trial.

What Should You Do If You Think Punitive Damages Apply?

If you were hurt by a drunk driver or by conduct that seemed reckless rather than careless, these steps help protect the claim:

  1. Get the police report and any criminal case number. An intoxication-related arrest or charge may bear on whether the cap exception applies.
  2. Preserve evidence quickly. Ask a lawyer to send preservation letters for dash camera footage, vehicle data, company records, and bar receipts.
  3. Do not give recorded statements to the other side's insurer before getting legal advice.
  4. Track every economic loss. Because the cap formula is based on economic damages, complete medical and wage records can affect the maximum exemplary award.
  5. Watch the deadline. Most Texas personal injury claims must be filed within two years. Our guide to time limits for personal injury claims in Texas covers the rules and exceptions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are punitive damages and exemplary damages the same thing in Texas?

Yes. Texas statutes use the term "exemplary damages," and § 41.001 states that the term includes punitive damages. Both refer to damages awarded to punish, not to compensate.

Is ordinary negligence ever enough for punitive damages?

No. Section 41.003(b) states that the burden of proof cannot be satisfied by evidence of ordinary negligence. The injured person must prove fraud, malice, or gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence.

What is the minimum cap on punitive damages in Texas?

The cap is never lower than $200,000. Under § 41.008(b), the maximum is the greater of $200,000 or two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000.

Does the cap apply if a drunk driver hit me?

Not when the claim is based on conduct described as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter. Section 41.008(c) removes the cap for those offenses without requiring proof that the conduct was knowing or intentional. You still must prove gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence.

Does the jury have to agree unanimously?

Yes. Exemplary damages may be awarded only if the jury is unanimous on both liability and the amount, and the court must instruct the jury on that requirement (§ 41.003(d)-(e)).

Can I get punitive damages without any actual damages?

No. Section 41.004(a) allows exemplary damages only if damages other than nominal damages are awarded.

Can a family recover punitive damages after a fatal crash?

Yes. Section 71.009 allows exemplary damages in a wrongful death case when the death is caused by a willful act or omission or gross negligence of the defendant.

Talk With a Fort Worth Personal Injury Lawyer

Punitive damages claims turn on evidence about what a defendant knew and chose to do, and that evidence can disappear quickly. If you or a family member was seriously injured by a drunk driver, a reckless company, or other dangerous conduct anywhere in Dallas-Fort Worth, HLAW can review the facts and explain the options. Call (817) 993-9249 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.

This article provides general information about Texas law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its specific facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Laws change, so consult a licensed Texas attorney about your situation.

Read full article
Injured man with a knee brace and crutches at a family dinner table as his wife rests a hand on his shoulder

Loss of Consortium in Texas: When Spouses and Children Can Recover After a Serious Injury

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: In Texas, a loss of consortium claim allows the spouse or child of a seriously injured person to recover damages for the harm the injury caused to their own relationship, such as lost affection, companionship, comfort, and emotional support. The Supreme Court of Texas recognized the claim for spouses in 1978 and for children of a parent with serious, permanent, and disabling injuries in 1990. However, Texas does not allow parents to recover for loss of consortium when a child is injured but survives, and because the claim is derivative, the injured person's own share of fault reduces or bars it.

Injured man with a knee brace and crutches at a family dinner table as his wife rests a hand on his shoulder

When someone is badly hurt in a crash on I-35W, a fall at a store, or a workplace accident in Dallas-Fort Worth, the injured person is not the only one who suffers. A spouse may lose a partner's companionship and help. A child may lose a parent's ability to play, teach, and be present. Texas law recognizes some of these losses, but the rules are specific, and many families do not know the claim exists until it is too late to raise it.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth personal injury lawyers represent injured people and their families in Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains who can bring a loss of consortium claim in Texas, what it covers, how it is valued, and the limits that often decide these cases.

Key Takeaways

  • Spouses can recover. In Whittlesey v. Miller, the Supreme Court of Texas held "that either spouse has a cause of action for loss of consortium" arising from an injury caused to the other spouse by a third party's negligence (Whittlesey v. Miller, Tex. 1978).
  • Children can recover when a parent is seriously injured. In Reagan v. Vaughn, the court held "that children may recover for loss of consortium when a third party causes serious, permanent, and disabling injuries to their parent" (Reagan v. Vaughn, Tex. 1990).
  • Parents of an injured child generally cannot. Texas does not recognize a common law claim for a parent's loss of consortium resulting from a non-fatal injury to a child (Roberts v. Williamson, Tex. 2003).
  • The claim is derivative. The defenses that bar all or part of the injured person's recovery have the same effect on the consortium claim, including the injured person's percentage of fault (Reagan v. Vaughn).
  • It is a noneconomic damage. Texas law lists "loss of consortium" among noneconomic damages, which matters for caps in medical malpractice cases (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §41.001; §74.301).
  • Deaths follow different rules. When an injury is fatal, family members' claims for loss of companionship generally proceed under the Texas Wrongful Death Act (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 71).

What Is Loss of Consortium in Texas?

"Consortium" refers to the intangible benefits of a close family relationship. In Whittlesey, the Supreme Court of Texas explained that consortium "can generally be defined to include the mutual right of the husband and wife to that affection, solace, comfort, companionship, society, assistance, and sexual relations necessary to a successful marriage." The court added that the definition "primarily consists of the emotional or intangible elements of the marital relationship" (Whittlesey v. Miller).

In other words, a loss of consortium claim is not about medical bills or lost paychecks. It compensates a family member for the harm to the relationship itself: the spouse who can no longer share activities, travel, or intimacy with a partner, or the child whose parent can no longer coach, comfort, or guide them the way they once did.

The court also noted that in Texas, spousal consortium "does not include the 'services' rendered by a spouse to the marriage." Household services, such as a spouse's lost ability to do chores, can be handled differently, so it is important to discuss with your lawyer how each type of loss is presented.

Who Can Bring a Loss of Consortium Claim in Texas?

Texas law draws clear lines about which relationships qualify when the injured person survives.

Relationship Injured person survives Key authority
Spouse of injured person Yes, a claim is recognized Whittlesey v. Miller (1978)
Child of injured parent Yes, if the parent's injuries are serious, permanent, and disabling Reagan v. Vaughn (1990)
Parent of injured child No common law claim for a non-fatal injury Roberts v. Williamson (2003)
Siblings, unmarried partners, other relatives Generally not recognized Texas common law

Spouses

A spouse's claim is the most common type. Whittlesey involved a wife whose husband was injured in a car accident, and the court held that either spouse may bring the claim. The court also held that a settlement signed by the husband did not end the wife's claim, because there was "no showing that the husband had the authority to enter into a settlement on behalf of his wife" (Whittlesey v. Miller). That is one reason the spouse's claim should be identified and resolved together with the injured person's claim.

Children of an injured parent

Under Reagan, the child may recover non-pecuniary damages for "loss of the parent's love, affection, protection, emotional support, services, companionship, care, and society." The court declined to limit the claim to minor children, noting that adult children may also recover, while leaving it to the jury to consider the child's age in setting damages. On rehearing, the court explained that when the facts are disputed, the jury must first find that the parent's injury "was a serious, permanent, and disabling injury" before deciding consortium damages (Reagan v. Vaughn).

When the child is a minor, any settlement of the child's claim generally requires court approval. Our guide to settling a child's injury claim in Texas explains that process.

Parents of an injured child

In Roberts v. Williamson, the Supreme Court of Texas decided whether Texas recognizes "a common law cause of action for a parent's loss of consortium resulting from a non-fatal injury to a child," and it declined to recognize one (Roberts v. Williamson). Parents of a seriously injured child may still have other claims, such as for medical expenses they paid, but a separate claim for the lost relationship is not available when the child survives.

How Is a Loss of Consortium Claim Proven?

Because the claim is derivative, the family member must first prove that the defendant is legally responsible for the injured person's injuries. In Reagan, the court said the plaintiff "must show that the defendant physically injured the child's parent in a manner that would subject the defendant to liability" (Reagan v. Vaughn).

Then the family member must show how the injury changed the relationship. Evidence often includes:

  1. Testimony from the spouse or child about the relationship before and after the injury.
  2. Testimony from friends, relatives, coworkers, or clergy who saw the change.
  3. Medical evidence of the injured person's limitations, prognosis, and permanency.
  4. Photos, videos, and records showing shared activities, trips, coaching, or hobbies before the injury.
  5. Counseling or mental health records, where relevant, showing the strain on the family.

Juries often respond to concrete, specific examples rather than general statements. A spouse who describes no longer being able to go on morning walks, dance at a family wedding, or share the work of raising children can help the jury understand the loss. Our article on emotional distress and PTSD claims discusses similar proof for the injured person's own mental anguish.

How Much Is a Loss of Consortium Claim Worth?

There is no formula. The jury decides an amount based on the evidence. For children, Reagan listed factors including "the severity of the injury to the parent and its actual effect upon the parent-child relationship, the child's age, the nature of the child's relationship with the parent, the child's emotional and physical characteristics, and whether other consortium giving relationships are available to the child" (Reagan v. Vaughn; see also Reeder v. Allport, Tex. App. 2007).

For spousal claims, similar considerations often matter: the length and quality of the marriage, how severe and permanent the injury is, and how much the couple's daily life has changed.

Several legal rules can limit what a family actually recovers:

  • Comparative fault. Under Texas's proportionate responsibility statute, a claimant "may not recover damages if his percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent," and otherwise damages are reduced by that percentage (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§33.001, 33.012). For consortium claims, Reagan held that "any percentage of negligence attributable against the parent" will reduce the child's recovery.
  • Medical malpractice caps. Loss of consortium is a noneconomic damage under §41.001. In health care liability claims, Chapter 74 limits noneconomic damages against physicians and providers to $250,000 for each claimant, with separate limits for health care institutions (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §74.301).
  • Insurance limits. In many DFW car wreck cases, the at-fault driver's policy limits are the practical ceiling, and the injured person and family members may be sharing the same limited coverage.
  • Workers' compensation. In Reed Tool Co. v. Copelin, the court held that a wife's negligence-based consortium claim against her husband's employer was barred where the husband was covered by workers' compensation (Reed Tool Co. v. Copelin, Tex. 1980). Claims against other at-fault parties, such as a negligent driver, may remain.

For a broader look at valuation, see what your personal injury case may be worth.

Is Loss of Consortium Different From a Wrongful Death Claim?

Yes. The cases above involve people who survive their injuries. When a person dies, the surviving spouse, children, and parents may bring a wrongful death action, which Texas law says is "for the exclusive benefit of the surviving spouse, children, and parents of the deceased" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §71.004). In Sanchez v. Schindler, the Supreme Court of Texas held that parents may recover for loss of companionship and society and mental anguish for the wrongful death of a child (Sanchez v. Schindler, Tex. 1983).

So while parents cannot recover consortium damages for a child who survives, they may recover for loss of companionship if the child dies. Learn more on our wrongful death practice page.

Who Owns the Money From a Consortium Claim?

The consortium claim belongs to the family member, not the injured person. Under the Texas Family Code, a spouse's separate property includes "the recovery for personal injuries sustained by the spouse during marriage, except any recovery for loss of earning capacity during marriage" (Tex. Fam. Code §3.001). In Reed Tool, the court described the wife's intentional consortium claim as her "separate property claim." How settlement funds are characterized can matter in later family law issues, so it is worth discussing with counsel when a settlement is divided.

How Long Do You Have to File?

Most Texas personal injury claims must be filed within two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code §16.003, and a spouse's consortium claim is typically brought alongside the injured spouse's claim within that period. For minors, §16.001 provides that the time a person is "younger than 18 years of age" is generally not included in the limitations period (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 16). Different deadlines and notice rules may apply to claims against governmental entities and health care providers. See our guide to time limits for personal injury claims in Texas.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue for loss of consortium if my husband or wife was hurt in a car accident?

Yes, Texas recognizes a spouse's claim when a third party's negligence injured the other spouse. You must show the defendant is liable for your spouse's injuries and prove how the injury harmed your marriage.

Does the injury have to be permanent for a spouse's claim?

Reagan expressly requires serious, permanent, and disabling injuries for a child's claim. For spouses, the severity and duration of the injury strongly affect the value of the claim, and minor, short-term injuries often support little or no consortium recovery. Talk with a lawyer about your specific facts.

Can my adult children bring a loss of consortium claim?

Possibly. In Reagan, the Supreme Court of Texas declined to limit the claim to minor children, while noting that the jury may consider the child's age in setting damages. The parent's injuries must still be serious, permanent, and disabling.

Can I recover loss of consortium if we are engaged but not married?

Texas generally limits spousal consortium to legally married spouses. A valid common law marriage under Texas law may qualify, but that must be proven.

Will my fault in the accident affect my spouse's consortium claim?

Yes. Because the claim is derivative, the injured person's percentage of responsibility reduces the family member's recovery, and if the injured person is more than 50 percent at fault, the claim may be barred.

Does the insurance company have to pay loss of consortium separately?

Consortium is a separate claim, but it is usually paid from the same liability policy as the injured person's claim. When coverage is limited, how the money is divided among family members becomes an important part of the settlement.

Talk to a Fort Worth Personal Injury Lawyer

A serious injury affects the whole family. Identifying every claim, including a spouse's or child's loss of consortium, helps ensure the family's losses are presented together and not left out of a settlement.

Call HLAW at (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation about a serious injury in Dallas-Fort Worth.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article
Father and young son with a blue arm cast waiting on a bench in a Texas courthouse hallway

Settling a Child's Injury Claim in Texas: Court Approval, Guardian Ad Litem, and Where the Money Goes

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: In Texas, a parent generally cannot simply sign a release and accept a check to settle a child's injury claim in a way that permanently binds the child. To make a settlement of a minor's claim final, the case is usually filed in court by a parent acting as "next friend," and the judge must approve the settlement after a hearing, often with a court-appointed guardian ad litem advising whether the deal is in the child's best interest. The child's share of the money is then protected until adulthood, often in the court registry, a court-created trust, or a structured settlement. Separately, the deadline for the child's own claim generally does not begin to run until the child turns 18, though waiting carries real risks.

Father and young son with a blue arm cast waiting on a bench in a Texas courthouse hallway

When a child is hurt in a car wreck, a dog attack, a fall, or another accident in Dallas-Fort Worth, parents often hear from an insurance company about settling quickly. Many are surprised to learn that a child's settlement follows special rules designed to protect the child, and that a release signed only by a parent may not end the child's claim.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth child injury lawyers help families in Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties through the full process, from the claim to court approval. This guide explains how minor settlements work in Texas, who protects the child's interests, and where the money goes.

Key Takeaways

  • Court approval makes a minor's settlement binding. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 44, a next friend "may with the approval of the court compromise suits," and approved compromises "shall be forever binding and conclusive" on the child (Tex. R. Civ. P. 44).
  • A hearing and evidence are required. Courts have held that a judgment approving a minor's settlement "cannot be rendered without a hearing and evidence that the settlement serves the minor's best interest" (Byrd v. Woodruff, as quoted by a federal court).
  • A guardian ad litem often reviews the deal. When a settlement is proposed, a guardian ad litem has "the limited duty to determine and advise the court whether the settlement is in the party's best interest" (Tex. R. Civ. P. 173.4(c)).
  • The money is protected until adulthood. Texas Property Code Chapter 142 allows a child's funds to be invested through the court clerk, placed in a court-created trust, or paid through a structured settlement (Tex. Prop. Code ch. 142).
  • Smaller, uncontested amounts can go to the court registry. Texas Estates Code Chapter 1355 allows payment into the court registry, without a guardianship, of $250,000 or less owed to a minor when the right to the money is liquidated and uncontested (Tex. Est. Code ch. 1355).
  • The child's own deadline is generally paused until 18. A person younger than 18 is under a "legal disability," and "the time of the disability is not included in a limitations period" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §16.001).

Why Do Child Injury Settlements Need Court Approval in Texas?

A minor cannot sign a binding contract to release a legal claim, and Texas law does not give parents unlimited power to give away a child's claim. Rule 44 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure provides that minors without a legal guardian "may sue and be represented by 'next friend,'" and that the next friend or the next friend's attorney "may with the approval of the court compromise suits and agree to judgments." When a court approves the compromise, it "shall be forever binding and conclusive upon the party plaintiff in such suit" (Tex. R. Civ. P. 44).

That court approval is what gives the person paying the settlement, usually an insurance company, the finality it wants, and it is also what protects the child. Without it, a release signed only by a parent may not prevent the child from bringing the claim later. For that reason, insurers and their lawyers commonly insist on court approval before paying a significant settlement of a child's claim.

How Does the Minor Settlement Process Work?

The process often goes like this:

  1. The claim is investigated and negotiated. As with any injury claim, the child's medical treatment, prognosis, and damages are documented, and the lawyer negotiates with the insurer. Our guide on what your personal injury case may be worth explains the factors involved. Mediation is common; see our guide to mediation in personal injury cases.
  2. A lawsuit is filed, often as a "friendly suit." If the case settles before a lawsuit is filed, the parties commonly file a suit so the court can approve the agreement. The parent sues as next friend of the child.
  3. The court may appoint a guardian ad litem. If the next friend appears to have an interest adverse to the child, such as when a parent and child are both receiving money from the same limited insurance policy, the court must appoint a guardian ad litem under Rule 173.2, and courts frequently do so in minor settlements.
  4. The guardian ad litem reviews the settlement. The ad litem evaluates the injuries, the settlement amount, how the money is divided, and how the child's share will be managed, and then reports to the court.
  5. The court holds a hearing. Often called a "prove-up" or "minor settlement hearing," the judge hears testimony, usually from the parent and the guardian ad litem, about the settlement and whether it is fair to the child.
  6. The court signs a judgment. The judgment approves the settlement, allocates the funds, approves attorney's fees and expenses, and orders how the child's share will be held until adulthood.

Many DFW minor settlement hearings are short, but the paperwork behind them is detailed, and the judge must be satisfied that the child is protected.

What Does a Guardian Ad Litem Do in a Child's Settlement?

A guardian ad litem is a person, usually a lawyer, appointed by the court to protect the child's interests in specific situations. Under Rule 173, a guardian ad litem serves as an officer and advisor to the court. When an offer has been made to settle the claim of a child represented by a next friend, the ad litem "has the limited duty to determine and advise the court whether the settlement is in the party's best interest" (Tex. R. Civ. P. 173).

According to the Corpus Christi-Edinburg Court of Appeals, the ad litem's duty includes "evaluating the damages suffered by the minor, the adequacy of the settlement, the proposed apportionment and manner of distribution of the settlement proceeds, and the amount of attorney's fees charged by the plaintiff's attorney" (Tex. App. Corpus Christi 2021).

Who pays the guardian ad litem?

Rule 173.6 allows a guardian ad litem to be reimbursed for reasonable expenses and "paid a reasonable hourly fee for necessary services performed." The court "must not consider compensation as a percentage of any judgment or settlement," and it "may tax a guardian ad litem's compensation as costs of court." In practice, the settlement agreement often addresses which party pays the ad litem's fee. Texas appellate courts have stressed that the ad litem's role is limited (Columbia Rio Grande Healthcare v. De Leon).

Where Does a Child's Settlement Money Go?

Texas law provides several ways to protect a child's money until adulthood. The court decides which option fits the case.

Option Legal source How it works Often used for
Court registry (Estates Code) Tex. Est. Code ch. 1355 Money is paid to the county clerk and invested for the child; it can generally be withdrawn when the child's disability ends Uncontested amounts of $250,000 or less
Court-ordered investment Tex. Prop. Code §142.004 Funds invested by the clerk on court order, or by the next friend in restricted accounts, including certain college savings plans, prepaid tuition programs, and ABLE accounts Many small and mid-size settlements
Section 142 trust Tex. Prop. Code §142.005 A court-created trust managed by a trustee, usually a financial institution, for the child's health, education, support, or maintenance Larger settlements or children with ongoing needs
Structured settlement Tex. Prop. Code §142.008 Periodic payments funded by a qualifying annuity or U.S. government obligation Long-term income planning
Guardianship of the estate Texas Estates Code A court-appointed guardian manages the funds under court supervision Situations where other options do not fit

The 142 trust in more detail

A trust under Property Code §142.005 must name the child as "the sole beneficiary of the trust." The trustee may make distributions it finds "reasonably necessary for the health, education, support, or maintenance of the beneficiary." For a minor who is not considered disabled for Supplemental Security Income purposes, the trust ends at the child's death, at an age stated in the trust, or "on the 25th birthday of the beneficiary, whichever occurs first." If the child is disabled under those federal rules, the trust ends at the child's death. Where the trust principal is more than $50,000, the court may appoint someone other than a financial institution as trustee only if no financial institution is willing to serve and the appointment is in the child's best interest (Tex. Prop. Code §142.005).

If your child receives or may need government benefits such as Medicaid or SSI, the way the money is held can matter. The statute allows the court to modify trust terms when necessary for the child to remain eligible for public benefits. Our article on how a personal injury settlement can affect government benefits explains these concerns.

Can parents use the settlement money?

Generally, the child's share belongs to the child, not the parents, and the court controls how it is used before the child reaches adulthood. A 142 trust can allow distributions for the child's health, education, support, or maintenance. Parents should not expect to use a child's funds for general household expenses.

How Are Medical Bills and Liens Handled?

A child's settlement often must account for medical bills and liens before the remaining funds are protected. Hospitals may file liens under Texas law, and health insurers or Medicaid may have reimbursement rights. These amounts are usually resolved as part of the settlement and disclosed to the court at the hearing. Our guide on hospital liens and your DFW injury settlement explains how liens work.

Parents may also have their own claims arising from the child's injury, such as for medical expenses they paid, and those claims can have different deadlines than the child's claim. A lawyer can help identify each claim and how it should be handled in the settlement.

How Long Do You Have to File a Claim for a Child's Injury in Texas?

Most Texas personal injury claims must be filed within two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code §16.003. For minors, §16.001 provides that a person "younger than 18 years of age" is under a legal disability, and "the time of the disability is not included in a limitations period" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §16.001). In general, that means the two-year period for the child's own claim does not begin to run until the child turns 18.

There are important cautions:

  • Some claims have different rules. Health care liability claims and claims against governmental entities can have their own deadlines and notice requirements, sometimes much shorter.
  • Parents' claims may not be paused. Claims belonging to the parents may be subject to the normal two-year deadline.
  • Evidence fades. Witnesses move, video is erased, and records become harder to obtain.

See our guide to time limits for personal injury claims in Texas for more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I just sign the insurance company's release for my child?

You should be cautious. Under Rule 44, a compromise of a minor's suit becomes "forever binding and conclusive" on the child when approved by the court. Without court approval, a parent-signed release may not bind the child, and signing it could affect your own claims. Talk with a lawyer before signing.

Does every child settlement need a lawsuit and a hearing?

Not always, but court approval is the standard way to make the settlement binding on the child, and insurers commonly require it for significant settlements. Smaller, uncontested payments to minors can sometimes be deposited in the court registry under Estates Code Chapter 1355.

Will my child have to testify at the settlement hearing?

Often not. The parent and the guardian ad litem usually provide the testimony. Some judges may want to see or hear from an older child, and practices vary by court.

When can my child get the money?

That depends on how the funds are held. Money in the court registry is generally available when the child turns 18. A 142 trust may continue until an age set in the trust, up to the child's 25th birthday for a child who is not disabled under federal SSI rules. Structured settlements pay on the schedule approved by the court.

How are attorney's fees handled in a child's settlement?

The court reviews and approves attorney's fees and expenses as part of the settlement, and a guardian ad litem may evaluate them. The fees must be disclosed and approved before the settlement is final.

What if both a parent and a child were hurt in the same crash?

When a parent and child share limited insurance coverage, their interests may conflict over how the money is divided. Rule 173 requires the court to appoint a guardian ad litem if the next friend appears to have an interest adverse to the child.

Talk to a Fort Worth Child Injury Lawyer

A child's injury claim involves more than negotiating a number. It requires careful documentation, court approval, and a plan to protect the money for your child's future. Our firm can help you understand each step.

Call HLAW at (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation about a child's injury in Dallas-Fort Worth.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article
Apartment complex walkway at dusk with a broken pedestrian gate, overgrown hedge, and dim stairwell lighting

Assaulted at a DFW Apartment Complex? When Texas Landlords Are Liable for Negligent Security

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: In Texas, an apartment owner can be held liable when a tenant or guest is assaulted, robbed, or otherwise hurt by a criminal on the property, but only in limited situations. Generally, the owner must have known or had reason to know of an unreasonable and foreseeable risk of that kind of crime, usually shown by similar prior crimes on or near the property, and must have failed to take reasonable steps to reduce it. Separately, the Texas Property Code requires landlords to provide specific locks and security devices and to rekey units between tenants. These claims are generally subject to a two-year deadline to file suit.

Apartment complex walkway at dusk with a broken pedestrian gate, overgrown hedge, and dim stairwell lighting

Being attacked where you live is frightening, and it is natural to ask whether the property should have done more. Broken gates, dark parking lots, missing deadbolts, and repeated break-ins that management ignored can all be part of a negligent security claim. Texas law, however, sets demanding rules for these cases, and the details matter.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth personal injury lawyers represent injured people and families throughout Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains how negligent security claims work in Texas, what the Texas Supreme Court requires, and what evidence tends to matter most.

Key Takeaways

  • The general rule favors property owners. The Texas Supreme Court has said that "generally, a premises owner has no duty to protect invitees from criminal acts by third parties," with an exception when the owner "knows or has reason to know of a risk of harm to invitees that is unreasonable and foreseeable" (Del Lago Partners v. Smith, Tex. 2010).
  • Prior crimes usually drive foreseeability. Courts weigh five Timberwalk factors: proximity, recency, frequency, similarity, and publicity of prior crimes (Timberwalk Apartments v. Cain, Tex. 1998).
  • Foreseeable is not enough by itself. In a 2017 case involving a shooting in an apartment visitor lot, the Texas Supreme Court held that a risk must be "both foreseeable and unreasonable," which also weighs the burden of preventing it (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie).
  • Texas law requires specific security devices. Without a tenant having to ask, a rental dwelling must have window latches, a doorknob lock or keyed dead bolt, sliding door pin locks and bars or handle latches, and a keyless bolting device and door viewer on each exterior door (Tex. Prop. Code §92.153).
  • Locks must be rekeyed between tenants. Landlords must rekey key, card, or combination devices within seven days after each tenant turnover (Tex. Prop. Code §92.156).
  • The criminal's share of fault counts. A defendant can ask the jury to assign responsibility to the attacker, even an unknown "John Doe," which can reduce what the property owner pays (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33).
  • Two years is the usual deadline. Personal injury suits generally must be filed "not later than two years after the day the cause of action accrues" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §16.003).

What Is a Negligent Security Claim in Texas?

A negligent security claim is a type of premises liability case. The injured person argues that the owner or manager of a property failed to use reasonable care to protect people on the property from a foreseeable crime, and that this failure was a cause of the injury.

These claims often arise from:

  • Assaults or robberies in apartment parking lots, breezeways, stairwells, and laundry rooms
  • Break-ins and home invasions where locks were missing, broken, or never rekeyed
  • Attacks through broken or propped-open access gates
  • Shootings or assaults at complexes with a known history of similar violence
  • Assaults in hotels, parking garages, bars, and retail centers

The person who committed the crime is always responsible for it. A negligent security claim asks a different question: whether the property owner also carries part of the responsibility because it ignored a risk it knew about or should have known about.

When Is a Texas Apartment Owner Responsible for a Crime on the Property?

Texas courts start from the rule that a property owner is generally not responsible for the criminal acts of others. Liability turns on whether the owner owed a legal duty in the situation, and that depends heavily on foreseeability.

The Timberwalk foreseeability factors

In Timberwalk Apartments, Partners, Inc. v. Cain, a Texas Supreme Court case involving the sexual assault of an apartment tenant, the court explained that "foreseeability of an unreasonable risk of criminal conduct is a prerequisite to imposing a duty of care" on someone who owns or controls premises (Timberwalk). Courts consider "whether any criminal conduct previously occurred on or near the property, how recently it occurred, how often it occurred, how similar the conduct was to the conduct on the property, and what publicity was given the occurrences."

Factor What courts look at Examples of helpful evidence
Proximity Crimes on the property or in its immediate vicinity Police reports for the complex address and adjacent properties
Recency How recently prior crimes happened Incidents in the months before the attack
Frequency How often crimes occurred A pattern of repeated incidents in a short period
Similarity Whether prior crimes put the owner on notice of the specific danger Prior assaults, robberies, or break-ins, not just minor property crimes
Publicity Whether the owner knew or should have known Tenant complaints, incident reports, emails to management, news coverage

The court added that these factors "must be considered together." It also explained that prior crimes do not need to be identical: a string of assaults and robberies can make other violent crimes foreseeable, while unreported crimes that no one knew about are not evidence of foreseeability. Courts have also said that property owners have no duty to regularly check criminal records for their area, though widely publicized crimes can show knowledge (Jai Jalaram v. LeRibeus, Tex. App. 2006).

The risk must also be unreasonable

In UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie (2017), a visitor was robbed and shot in the knee in the public visitor parking lot of a Texas apartment complex. The Texas Supreme Court reversed a judgment for the visitor and explained: "We have consistently said that a risk must be both foreseeable and unreasonable to impose a duty on a property owner" (UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie). Because the visitor offered no evidence about the burden of preventing or reducing the risk, the court rendered judgment for the complex.

The practical lesson is that a strong case needs two kinds of proof: evidence that the crime was foreseeable, and evidence that reasonable, available steps (such as repairing a gate, fixing lighting, or responding to repeated reports) could have reduced the risk.

When danger is imminent

Foreseeability can also come from what is happening in the moment. In Del Lago Partners v. Smith, the court upheld a verdict against a resort bar that "had actual and direct knowledge that a violent brawl was imminent between drunk, belligerent patrons and had ample time and means to defuse the situation" (Del Lago). The court stressed that the duty "arose not because of prior similar criminal conduct but because it was aware of an unreasonable risk of harm at the bar that very night," and that it was not announcing a general rule.

What Security Devices Must Texas Landlords Provide?

Separate from the general negligence rules, Subchapter D of Chapter 92 of the Texas Property Code sets specific security device requirements for residential rentals (Tex. Prop. Code ch. 92).

Under §92.153, unless an exception applies, and without a tenant having to ask, a dwelling must have:

  1. A window latch on each exterior window
  2. A doorknob lock or keyed dead bolt on each exterior door
  3. A sliding door pin lock on each exterior sliding glass door
  4. A sliding door handle latch or security bar on each exterior sliding glass door
  5. A keyless bolting device and a door viewer on each exterior door

Other key rules include:

  • Rekeying: Under §92.156(a), security devices operated by a key, card, or combination must be rekeyed at the landlord's expense "not later than the seventh day after each tenant turnover date."
  • Repairs: Under §92.158, a landlord must repair or replace a security device on request or notice that it is inoperable.
  • Timing: Under §92.161, repair and rekeying requests are presumed due within seven days, but within 72 hours if the tenant told the landlord about an unauthorized entry in the unit, an attempted or actual entry in another unit in the past two months, or a crime of personal violence at the complex in the past two months.

If a landlord does not comply with §92.153 or §92.156(a), §92.164 lets a tenant seek remedies including actual damages. The statute's attorney's fee provisions do not apply in suits for personal injuries or wrongful death. In practice, a missing or broken required lock is often powerful evidence in a broader negligence claim, especially when the tenant reported it in writing.

How Does the Attacker's Fault Affect the Claim?

Texas uses proportionate responsibility. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, the jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to each claimant, defendant, settling person, and designated "responsible third party" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §33.003).

That matters in negligent security cases because:

  • The attacker can be on the verdict form. Even if the attacker was never identified, §33.004(j) allows a defendant to designate an unknown person as a responsible third party if it timely pleads facts showing a reasonable probability that the person's act was criminal.
  • A defendant generally pays only its own share. Under §33.013(a), a liable defendant is generally responsible for its own percentage, unless its share is greater than 50 percent, in which case it is jointly and severally liable under §33.013(b)(1).
  • The injured person's own fault can reduce or bar recovery. Under §33.001, a claimant cannot recover if his or her percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. Our guide to how fault works in Texas personal injury cases explains these rules in more detail.

What Evidence Matters in a DFW Negligent Security Case?

Because these cases turn on what the owner knew before the attack, evidence often disappears quickly. Useful evidence can include:

  • Police call and incident records for the complex and nearby properties, often obtained through public information requests to the local police department
  • Management records such as incident reports, tenant complaints, work orders for gates, lights, and locks, and emails or portal messages
  • Your lease and any lease addenda, including security device and crime-related notices
  • Photos and video of broken gates, burned-out lights, damaged locks, or overgrown landscaping, taken as soon as possible
  • Surveillance video, which many properties record over within days or weeks
  • Security contracts and patrol logs, if the property used a guard or courtesy officer service
  • Witness information from neighbors who reported prior problems

A prompt written request to preserve video and records can be important. Insurance carriers for apartment owners often investigate quickly; our article on insurance adjuster tactics in Fort Worth explains what to watch for.

What Should You Do After Being Assaulted at an Apartment Complex?

  1. Get to safety and call 911. A police report documents the crime and its location.
  2. Get medical care right away, and keep records of every visit. Injuries such as head trauma and emotional harm may not be fully apparent at first.
  3. Report the incident to management in writing and keep a copy.
  4. Photograph the scene, including gates, lighting, locks, and doors, before repairs are made.
  5. Write down what you remember and the names of anyone who saw what happened or reported earlier problems.
  6. Avoid giving recorded statements to the property's insurer before getting legal advice, and be careful about what you post on social media.
  7. Talk with a lawyer early, so evidence can be requested before it is lost and the two-year filing deadline is protected.

If a loved one was killed in a crime at a property, the family may have a wrongful death claim. See our wrongful death practice page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue my apartment complex if I was robbed in the parking lot?

Possibly. You would generally need to show that the complex knew or should have known of an unreasonable and foreseeable risk of that kind of crime, often through similar prior crimes on or near the property, and that it failed to take reasonable steps that would have reduced the risk. Each case depends on its facts.

Does a single prior crime make an attack foreseeable?

Usually not by itself. The Texas Supreme Court has said that "the complete absence of previous crimes, or the occurrence of a few crimes over an extended time period, negates the foreseeability element," while a significant number of crimes in a short time strengthens it (Timberwalk). The more similar the prior crimes, the fewer may be needed.

Is a broken gate or burned-out light enough to win a case?

Not on its own. A broken gate or dark area can be important evidence that reasonable precautions were not taken, but Texas courts also require proof that the crime was foreseeable and that the risk was unreasonable. Written reports to management about the problem can strengthen the claim.

Can guests and visitors bring negligent security claims?

Yes, guests and other invitees can bring these claims. The visitor in Petrie was in a complex's visitor lot. The same foreseeability and unreasonableness rules apply.

Does it matter that the attacker was never caught?

A claim can proceed even if the attacker is unknown. The defendant may ask to designate the unknown person as a responsible third party under §33.004(j), and the jury may then assign that person a percentage of responsibility.

How long do I have to file a negligent security lawsuit in Texas?

Generally two years from the date of the injury under §16.003. Exceptions can apply, such as for minors, so it is best to get advice promptly.

Do these rules apply to hotels, bars, and stores too?

Yes. The Timberwalk foreseeability factors are applied to many kinds of commercial property, and Del Lago involved a resort bar. Our article on parking lot and sidewalk injuries in Texas covers other premises claims.

Talk to a Fort Worth Premises Liability Lawyer

Negligent security cases are fact-intensive and often hard-fought. Early investigation into prior crimes, complaints, and repairs can make a significant difference.

Call HLAW at (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation about an injury at a Dallas-Fort Worth apartment complex or other property.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article
Injured rider sitting on a downtown curb beside a fallen electric scooter in a bike lane, with a stopped car nearby

Hurt on an Electric Scooter in Dallas-Fort Worth? Texas E-Scooter Accident Laws and Your Rights

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: If you were hurt on an electric scooter in Dallas-Fort Worth because a driver, property owner, or city was negligent, you can generally bring a Texas personal injury claim. You can recover as long as you were not more than 50 percent responsible, and your recovery is reduced by your share of fault. Texas law treats a motor-assisted scooter much like a bicycle, not a motor vehicle. Where you were allowed to ride, whether city rules were followed, and which insurance applies often decide these cases. Claims against a city can require written notice within six months or less, and most lawsuits must be filed within two years.

Injured rider sitting on a downtown curb beside a fallen electric scooter in a bike lane, with a stopped car nearby

Electric scooters are now part of daily traffic in Deep Ellum, downtown Fort Worth, Arlington's entertainment district, and college areas across the Metroplex. They are convenient, but a rider has almost no protection in a collision with a car or a fall caused by a pothole. The legal rules are also less familiar than those for a typical car wreck.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth trial lawyers handle personal injury claims across Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains how Texas law applies to e-scooter crashes, who may be responsible, and what to do to protect a claim.

Key Takeaways

  • Scooters follow bicycle rules, not motor vehicle rules. Under Texas Transportation Code §551.352, bicycle provisions generally apply to a motor-assisted scooter, and "a provision of this title applicable to a motor vehicle does not apply to a motor-assisted scooter" (Tex. Transp. Code §551.352).
  • State law limits scooters to streets with posted speed limits of 35 mph or less, though riders may cross faster roads at intersections. Cities can add their own restrictions.
  • Dallas bans sidewalk riding. The City of Dallas says scooters "may not be ridden on or in: sidewalks, trails, parks, plazas, on roads with a speed limit of 35 MPH or higher," with a 20 mph citywide speed limit (City of Dallas).
  • Fault is shared under the 51 percent bar. A claimant "may not recover damages if his percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent," and any recovery is reduced by the claimant's percentage (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33).
  • Claims against a city have short notice deadlines. The Texas Tort Claims Act requires notice within six months, and city charters can set shorter periods (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §101.101).
  • Injuries are rising nationally. The CPSC estimates 380,000 emergency department visits involving e-scooters from 2017 through 2024 (CPSC micromobility report).

What Does Texas Law Say About Electric Scooters?

Texas regulates motor-assisted scooters in Chapter 551 of the Transportation Code. A "motor-assisted scooter" is a self-propelled device with at least two wheels, a braking system, a gas or electric motor, a deck designed for the rider to stand or sit, and "the ability to be propelled by human power alone" (Tex. Transp. Code §551.351). Most rental and privately owned stand-up e-scooters in DFW fall into this category.

The key operating rules are in §551.352 (Tex. Transp. Code §551.352):

  • A scooter "may be operated only on a street or highway for which the posted speed limit is 35 miles per hour or less," but may cross a faster road at an intersection.
  • A person may ride "on a path set aside for the exclusive operation of bicycles or on a sidewalk," unless a city or county prohibits it.
  • A county or city may prohibit scooters on a street, highway, or sidewalk "in the interest of safety."
  • Rules for bicycles generally apply to scooters, while rules for motor vehicles do not.

That last point matters in an injury case. A scooter rider generally has the rights and duties of a bicyclist on the road. Drivers owe scooter riders the same care they owe cyclists. For more on those rules, see our guide to bicycle accident claims in DFW.

How Do Dallas and Fort Worth Rules Differ?

Local rules vary across the Metroplex, and they can affect both safety and fault.

Issue Texas state law City of Dallas City of Fort Worth
Sidewalk riding Allowed unless a city or county prohibits it Not allowed, except to start or end a ride Generally follows state law; riders may use sidewalks and paths unless posted otherwise
Road speed limit Streets posted 35 mph or less Not on roads posted 35 mph or higher Streets posted 35 mph or less
Scooter speed No speed cap stated in §551.352 20 mph citywide; 10 mph in slow-ride zones City code does not directly address e-scooters
Rental age Not addressed in §551.352 No rentals to people under 16 City code does not directly address e-scooters

Sources: Tex. Transp. Code §551.352; City of Dallas Dockless Vehicle Program; Fort Worth Star-Telegram; Government Technology.

In Dallas, the city also lists no-ride zones, including parks, plazas, and most trails, and says riders who break the rules can be fined up to $200 under Section 28-41.1.1 of the Dallas City Code (City of Dallas). The Fort Worth Star-Telegram reported that Fort Worth police say e-scooters "can be ridden on bike paths and sidewalks, but they are restricted to streets with a posted speed limit of 35 mph or less" (Star-Telegram). Arlington, Denton, Plano, Irving, and other cities have their own rules, so the location of a crash matters.

Who Is Liable for an E-Scooter Accident in Texas?

Most scooter injury claims fall into one of four categories.

A driver who hit the rider

The most serious scooter injuries often involve cars. CPSC staff have reported that "the top hazards in e-scooter and e-bike fatalities were incidents with motor vehicles and user-control issues" (CPSC). Common scenarios include right hooks at intersections, left turns across a bike lane, drivers opening doors into a rider's path, and drivers backing out of driveways or parking spaces. A claim against the driver is a negligence claim, usually paid through the driver's liability insurance.

A property owner or business

Falls on private property, such as a parking garage, apartment complex, or shopping center, may involve premises liability if a dangerous condition caused the crash. Our article on parking lot and sidewalk injuries in Texas explains how those claims work.

A city or other government entity

Potholes, broken pavement, missing signs, and road construction can cause serious scooter falls. Claims against a city fall under the Texas Tort Claims Act, which has special rules. For a premise defect, the government generally owes only the duty a private person owes a licensee, but that limit does not apply to the duty to warn of "special defects such as excavations or obstructions on highways, roads, or streets" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §101.022). The Act also caps a city's liability at $250,000 per person for bodily injury. If a city vehicle hit you, see our guide to government vehicle accident claims in DFW.

The scooter company or manufacturer

Brake failures, throttle malfunctions, battery fires, and other defects can support a product liability or negligence claim against a manufacturer or operator. Rental apps usually require riders to accept terms of service, which may include arbitration clauses or liability waivers. Whether those terms are enforceable depends on their wording and the facts, so they should be reviewed before you assume a claim is barred.

Can You Recover if You Were Partly at Fault?

Often, yes. Texas uses proportionate responsibility. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code §33.001, a claimant "may not recover damages if his percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent." If you are 50 percent or less at fault, §33.012 reduces your damages by your percentage of responsibility (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33).

Insurers often argue that a scooter rider was at fault for riding on a Dallas sidewalk, riding on a road posted above 35 mph, riding at night without lights, carrying a passenger, or wearing headphones. These facts can reduce a claim, but they do not automatically defeat it. A driver who runs a red light or turns into a rider's path still bears responsibility. Our guide to how fault works in Texas personal injury cases explains how juries allocate responsibility.

What Insurance Pays for a Scooter Accident?

Insurance in a scooter case can come from several sources:

  1. The at-fault driver's liability coverage. Texas requires minimum limits of $30,000 per person for bodily injury (Texas Department of Insurance).
  2. Your own auto policy. Personal injury protection (PIP) is defined by statute as coverage for the named insured, "members of the insured's household," and authorized operators or passengers of the insured's vehicle for medical expenses and lost income arising from an accident (Tex. Ins. Code §1952.151). Whether your policy covers a scooter crash depends on its specific language, so review it before assuming it does not apply.
  3. Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. If the driver who hit you had no insurance or not enough, your own UM/UIM coverage may help. See our guide to UM/UIM and PIP auto insurance.
  4. Health insurance. Health insurance may pay medical bills, but it may claim reimbursement from any settlement.
  5. Homeowner's, renter's, or business policies, in some cases involving private property or a commercial defendant.

If the driver left the scene, our article on hit-and-run crashes in Texas explains next steps.

What Should You Do After an E-Scooter Crash in DFW?

  1. Get medical care right away. CPSC reports that fractures, followed by contusions and abrasions, are the most common micromobility injuries, and that the head and neck are among the most frequently injured areas (CPSC). Some head injuries are not obvious at first.
  2. Call the police if a vehicle was involved or anyone was hurt, and ask for the report number.
  3. Photograph everything: the scooter, the vehicle, the road surface, the lane markings, posted speed limit signs, and your injuries.
  4. Screenshot the rental app. Save the ride history, the start and end times, and the route. Rental companies may keep GPS and speed data that can show where and how fast you were riding.
  5. Keep the scooter if you own it, and do not repair it. If it was a rental, report the crash to the operator in writing and ask them to preserve the device and its data.
  6. Collect witness names and look for cameras. Businesses, buses, and doorbell cameras often capture crashes, but footage may be overwritten quickly.
  7. Be careful with insurance adjusters. Do not give a recorded statement about fault before you understand your rights.
  8. Note the deadlines. Notice to a city may be due within six months or less, and most personal injury lawsuits must be filed within two years. See our guide to the Texas statute of limitations.

What Compensation Is Available After a Scooter Injury?

Depending on the facts, a scooter rider may seek medical expenses, lost wages and loss of earning capacity, physical pain and mental anguish, physical impairment, disfigurement, and property damage. Because riders have little protection, scooter crashes can cause broken wrists and arms, facial injuries, dental injuries, and traumatic brain injuries. These injuries can require surgery and long recovery periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it legal to ride an electric scooter on the sidewalk in Texas?

State law allows scooters on sidewalks and bike paths, but cities can prohibit sidewalk riding. Dallas prohibits riding scooters on sidewalks except to start or end a ride. Fort Worth police have said scooters can be ridden on sidewalks and bike paths. Check the rules for the city where you are riding.

Can I sue if a car hit me while I was riding a rental scooter?

Generally, yes. A driver who causes a crash through negligence, such as failing to yield or turning into a bike lane, can be held responsible. The claim usually goes through the driver's liability insurance. Your own fault, if any, can reduce the recovery under Texas's proportionate responsibility rules.

Does a scooter rental waiver stop me from suing?

Not necessarily. A rental company's terms may limit claims against the company, and some require arbitration. Those terms generally do not protect a negligent driver or property owner who is not a party to the agreement. Whether a waiver applies to a claim against the company depends on its language and the facts.

What if a pothole caused my scooter crash?

You may have a claim against the city or other government entity responsible for the road, but the Texas Tort Claims Act limits these claims. You must give notice within six months, or less under some city charters, and there are damage caps and special rules for road defects.

Do I need to wear a helmet on an e-scooter in Texas?

The state scooter statute, §551.352, does not include a helmet requirement. Some cities set their own rules for children; for example, a Dallas ordinance makes it an offense for a parent to allow a child to ride a scooter without a helmet (Dallas Ordinance 20-0468). Not wearing a helmet may be raised by an insurer, but it does not by itself bar a claim against a negligent driver.

How long do I have to file a scooter accident claim in Texas?

Most personal injury lawsuits must be filed within two years. Claims against a government entity require much earlier notice, often within six months. It is best to talk to a lawyer as soon as possible.

Talk to a Fort Worth Scooter Accident Lawyer

If you or a family member was hurt in an electric scooter crash in Dallas-Fort Worth, HLAW can help you identify who was responsible, which insurance applies, and which deadlines matter.

Call HLAW at (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation.

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and every case depends on its specific facts.

Read full article

Speak with a Fort Worth attorney

Call (817) 993-9249 or send us a message to discuss your case.