Skip to content
Tag

Medical Records

2 articles

Injured man in an arm sling reviewing hospital bills and a patient wristband at his kitchen table after a Dallas-Fort Worth car wreck

Who Gets Paid First? Hospital Liens, Health Insurance Reimbursement, and Your DFW Injury Settlement

By Luke A. Williams · Personal Injury

Short answer: In Texas, a hospital that treats you within 72 hours of an accident caused by someone else's negligence can place a lien on your injury claim. That lien is capped at the lesser of the hospital's charges for the first 100 days of care or 50% of your recovery. Health insurers, Medicare, and some government plans may also have a right to be repaid from your settlement. The amount you ultimately keep depends heavily on how those claims are identified, challenged, and negotiated before the case closes.

Injured man in an arm sling reviewing hospital bills and a patient wristband at his kitchen table after a Dallas-Fort Worth car wreckMost people injured in a Dallas-Fort Worth car wreck, truck crash, or fall focus on one number: the settlement offer. But the settlement number and the amount that actually reaches you are rarely the same. Between the two sits a layer of liens and reimbursement claims that many injured people never hear about until they are asked to sign a release.

At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), lien resolution is part of every personal injury case we handle, and it is often where a meaningful part of a client's net recovery is won or lost. This guide explains how the system works in Texas and what you can do about it.

Key Takeaways

  • Texas hospital liens arise under Chapter 55 of the Texas Property Code. They attach to your claim, judgment, or settlement, not to your home or other property.
  • The 72-hour rule matters. A hospital lien attaches only if you were admitted within 72 hours of the accident, and Texas law treats being allowed into any department of the hospital, including the emergency room, as an admission.
  • There is a 50% cap. A hospital lien cannot exceed half of what you recover, and it does not cover charges above a "reasonable and regular rate."
  • Your recoverable medical damages are limited to what was actually paid or owed. Under Texas's "paid or incurred" rule, the inflated sticker price on a hospital bill is generally not what a jury will see.
  • Health insurers usually have to share attorney's fees and are capped as well. Texas Chapter 140 limits many health plans' reimbursement claims, though self-funded employer plans and Medicare follow different rules.
  • An unresolved lien can delay or invalidate a settlement. A release signed without satisfying a properly filed hospital lien is not valid against the hospital.

What Is a Hospital Lien in Texas?

A hospital lien is a legal claim a hospital holds against the money you recover from the person or company that caused your injury. Under Texas Property Code § 55.002, a hospital has a lien on the cause of action or claim of a person who receives hospital services for injuries caused by an accident attributed to another person's negligence.

According to Section 55.003, the lien attaches to three things:

  1. Your cause of action for damages arising from the injury,
  2. Any judgment you obtain in court, and
  3. The proceeds of any settlement.

Importantly, the hospital lien statute requires the hospital's notice to tell you that the lien does not attach to real property you own. In other words, a Chapter 55 lien follows the injury claim, not your house.

The 72-Hour Requirement

For a hospital lien to attach, you must have been admitted to the hospital no later than 72 hours after the accident, as stated in Section 55.002(a). Many people assume that a trip to the emergency room without an overnight stay is not an "admission." Texas law says otherwise. Since 2019, Section 55.0015 has provided that a person is considered admitted if they are allowed access to any department of the hospital for treatment, care, or service.

Practically, that means if you were taken to an emergency room in Fort Worth, Arlington, Dallas, or anywhere else in Texas within three days of a wreck, you should assume a lien may exist.

The lien also extends to a second hospital if you were transferred for treatment of the same injury, under Section 55.002(b).

How Much Can a Texas Hospital Lien Be?

This is where the statute offers real protection. Under Section 55.004(b), a hospital lien is limited to the lesser of:

  1. The hospital's charges for services during the first 100 days of your hospitalization;
  2. 50% of all amounts you recover through a lawsuit, judgment, or settlement; or
  3. If a jury specifies the amount awarded for hospital charges, that amount minus a pro rata share of your reasonable attorney's fees and expenses.

The lien also may not include charges that exceed a reasonable and regular rate for the services, according to Section 55.004(d). That language is a frequent starting point for negotiating hospital balances that are far above what the same hospital accepts from insurers.

The lien may also include certain emergency physician charges from the first seven days of hospitalization, but not physician charges that were already paid through insurance or that the physician is entitled to collect from your health plan under an assignment of benefits, per Section 55.004(c)–(d).

What About the Ambulance?

Texas also allows emergency medical services (EMS) providers to claim a lien, but only for EMS provided in a county with a population of 800,000 or less, and the lien is capped at $1,000, as provided by Sections 55.002(c) and 55.004(f).

This has a distinctly local effect in North Texas. Tarrant, Dallas, Collin, and Denton counties each had more than 900,000 residents at the 2020 Census, according to North Central Texas Council of Governments population data. Smaller surrounding counties such as Johnson, Parker, Wise, and Hood are well under that threshold. So whether an ambulance company can assert a lien may depend on which side of a county line the wreck happened.

How a Hospital Secures (and Loses) Its Lien

A hospital does not automatically hold an enforceable lien just because it treated you. Under Section 55.005, the hospital must:

  • File a written notice of lien with the county clerk in the county where services were provided, before money is paid to the injured person; and
  • Mail notice to the injured person (or their representative) within five business days after the clerk records it.

The notice must identify the injured person, the date of the accident, the hospital, and the person alleged to be liable, if known.

Once a lien is properly secured, it has teeth. Under Section 55.007, a release of your claim is not valid against the hospital unless the hospital's charges were paid (in full, or to the extent of the consideration paid), or the hospital is a party to the release. This is why liability insurers routinely run county lien searches and add hospitals as co-payees on settlement checks.

For an injured person, this has two consequences:

  • You cannot simply ignore a lien and expect the insurance company to pay you directly.
  • Your lawyer needs to identify liens early, by checking county records in places like Tarrant, Dallas, and Denton counties, so they can be challenged and negotiated before the settlement is finalized, rather than discovered at the last minute.

The "Paid or Incurred" Rule: Why Sticker Prices Don't Control

Texas hospitals often bill at full "chargemaster" rates that few patients or insurers actually pay. Texas law limits what you can recover for past medical expenses to the amount actually paid or incurred.

Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 41.0105 provides that recovery of medical or health care expenses "is limited to the amount actually paid or incurred by or on behalf of the claimant." In Haygood v. De Escabedo, the Texas Supreme Court held that this statute limits both recovery and the evidence presented at trial to expenses that the provider has a legal right to be paid. In that case, roughly $110,000 in billed charges was reduced to about $27,700 after required Medicare adjustments, as summarized by Chamberlain Hrdlicka.

Why does this matter for liens? Because the same gap between "billed" and "owed" that limits what a defendant must pay also gives an experienced attorney leverage to negotiate down hospital balances and reimbursement claims.

A note on 2025 legislation: In 2025, the Texas Legislature considered Senate Bill 30, which would have further changed how medical expenses are proven in injury cases. The bill ended in conference and did not become law, according to Phelps Dunbar, which notes it could return when the Legislature convenes on January 12, 2027. We will continue to monitor any changes.

When Your Health Insurer Wants to Be Repaid

If your own health insurance paid your medical bills after the wreck, your policy very likely contains a subrogation or reimbursement clause. That clause lets the insurer seek repayment from your injury settlement.

For many Texas-regulated health plans, Chapter 140 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code caps that recovery. When you are represented by an attorney, the payor's share is the lesser of:

  • One-half of your gross recovery, less attorney's fees and procurement costs; or
  • The total benefits the plan paid as a result of the injury, less attorney's fees and procurement costs.

Chapter 140 also states that the common-law "made whole" doctrine does not apply to these payors, according to Section 140.005(d). The statute applies to insurance companies, HMOs, and certain public employee plans listed in Section 140.002.

The important exception: Self-funded employer health plans governed by the federal ERISA statute are often not bound by state anti-subrogation rules like Chapter 140. The U.S. Supreme Court's decision in FMC Corp. v. Holliday is the foundation for that rule. These plans are governed by the specific language in the plan documents, which is why requesting and reviewing the actual plan document is a critical step in any case involving employer-provided coverage.

Medicare and Other Government Payors

If you are a Medicare beneficiary, federal law treats Medicare as a "secondary payer" when liability insurance is responsible for an injury. According to CMS, Medicare can make "conditional payments" for accident-related care, but those payments must be repaid when you receive a settlement, judgment, or award.

CMS guidance on the recovery process explains that a pending liability case must be reported to the Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC), and that the settlement date, amount, and attorney's fees and procurement costs must be reported when the case resolves. Medicare's final demand accounts for a proportionate share of those procurement costs, as described in the Medicare Secondary Payer Manual.

Medicare claims are not something to handle casually. Federal law gives the government strong collection rights, so these claims should be resolved through the proper process, with related-versus-unrelated charges carefully reviewed before the final demand is paid. Medicaid, VA, TRICARE, and workers' compensation carriers each have their own separate recovery rules.

A Simple Example

Imagine a Fort Worth driver is rear-ended on I-35W, taken to an emergency room, and later treated with physical therapy. The case settles for $100,000.

  • The hospital files a lien for $40,000 in charges.
  • The driver's health plan paid $15,000 toward therapy and imaging.

Without careful lien work, the driver might assume that roughly $55,000 of the settlement is gone before fees and costs. In practice, the hospital lien is limited to its reasonable and regular rate (and can never exceed $50,000, which is 50% of the recovery), and a Chapter 140-governed health plan must reduce its claim by its share of attorney's fees. Negotiation of each balance can further reduce the amounts owed.

Every case is different, and the actual numbers depend on the type of plan, the bills, and the facts, but the example shows why lien resolution is not a clerical afterthought. It directly determines how much of your settlement you keep.

What You Should Do After a DFW Accident

  1. Keep every bill, explanation of benefits (EOB), and letter you receive from hospitals, ambulance companies, and insurers.
  2. Do not ignore a lien notice in the mail. It is often the first sign that a hospital has recorded a lien with the county clerk.
  3. Give your providers your health insurance information. Hospitals sometimes prefer to file a lien for full charges instead of billing your insurer at negotiated rates. Insisting that your insurance be billed can significantly reduce what is owed.
  4. Tell your attorney if you have Medicare, Medicaid, or an employer health plan, and find out whether your employer plan is fully insured or self-funded.
  5. Do not sign a release or accept a check until every lien and reimbursement claim has been identified and addressed.
  6. Talk to an injury lawyer who handles liens directly, rather than a high-volume firm that hands lien work to a settlement processor. (Learn more about why that difference matters.)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Texas hospital put a lien on my house after a car wreck?

No. A Chapter 55 hospital lien attaches to your injury claim, judgment, or settlement. The statute requires the hospital to tell you that the lien does not attach to real property you own, as stated in Texas Property Code § 55.005(d).

Does a hospital lien apply if I only went to the emergency room?

Usually yes. Texas treats access to any department of the hospital, including the ER, as an admission under Section 55.0015, as long as it occurred within 72 hours of the accident.

Can a hospital lien take my entire settlement?

No. A hospital lien under Chapter 55 cannot exceed 50% of the amounts you recover, and it is limited to the lesser of that cap, the first 100 days of charges, or a jury-specified amount reduced by attorney's fees, under Section 55.004(b).

Does a hospital lien attach to my own insurance coverage?

Generally, a Chapter 55 lien does not attach to proceeds of an insurance policy in favor of the injured person, except liability insurance that protects against loss from an accident or collision, according to Section 55.003(b). How this applies to a particular PIP or uninsured/underinsured motorist claim should be reviewed by your attorney. (See our guide to UM/UIM and PIP coverage in Texas.)

Does my health insurance company get paid back out of my settlement?

Often yes, if your policy has a reimbursement clause. For many Texas-regulated plans, Chapter 140 limits the insurer to the lesser of half your recovery or the benefits it paid, each reduced by attorney's fees and costs. Self-funded ERISA plans may follow different rules.

Will lien negotiations delay my settlement?

They can add time, but resolving them correctly protects you. A release given without satisfying a properly secured hospital lien is not valid against that hospital under Section 55.007, which is why insurers insist that liens be addressed before they pay.

Talk to a Fort Worth Personal Injury Attorney

At HLAW, a partner personally handles your case from the first call through the final disbursement, including the lien and reimbursement negotiations that determine how much of your settlement you actually keep. We represent injured people across Fort Worth, Keller, Southlake, Grapevine, Arlington, Dallas, and the greater Dallas-Fort Worth area in car wreck, truck accident, wrongful death, and other personal injury cases.

If you've been hurt and are worried about medical bills or hospital liens, contact Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC or call (817) 993-9249 for a free consultation.


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Lien and reimbursement rules depend on the specific facts, plan documents, and current law; consult an attorney about your situation.

Read full article
HIPAA Medical Record Search Warrant DWI

HIPAA Does Not Bar Admissibility of Private Medical Records in Criminal Case

By Jason H. Howard · DWI, Evidence

Does HIPAA Impact Fourth Amendment Standing When the State Obtains Medical Records in a Criminal Investigation?

HIPAA Medical Record Search Warrant DWIWe’ve all signed the “HIPAA” privacy statements at the doctor’s office before treatment. The HIPAA Privacy Rule mandates nationwide standards to protect our medical records and personal health information by establishing safeguards, such as disclosure rules, patient authorization, and uniform protocols for the electronic transmission of medical data. HIPAA also grants patients the right to their own health information, but what about others? Does HIPAA prohibit the release of health information in a criminal investigation? What if that information is obtained via a grand jury subpoena?

State v. Huse (Tex. Crim. App. 2016)

One Month After Car Accident, Man is Charged with DWI

On February 13, 2010, Hayden Huse ran off the road and crashed into a cotton field at two in the morning. When law enforcement responded to the scene, they smelled alcohol on Huse’s breath. Instead of giving him a sobriety test, they transported him to the local hospital for injuries he sustained. During the medical exam, the hospital ran routine blood work. A few hours later during an interview with law enforcement, Huse admitted that he consumed six or seven alcoholic drinks the previous evening. However, he refused law enforcement’s request for a breath or blood specimen for blood alcohol analysis.

One month later, based upon the police report taken of Huse’s car accident, a Lubbock County Assistant District Attorney filed an application for a grand jury subpoena to obtain Huse’s medical records from the hospital, even though no grand jury had been investigating Huse. The hospital complied with the subpoena, providing Huse’s medical records, along with a business records affidavit. The records revealed that approximately two hours after the car accident, Huse’s blood alcohol concentration was .219—an amount well above the legal limit.

Huse Files a Motion to Suppress the Evidence

Huse filed a motion to suppress the records at a suppression hearing. The trial court granted his motion to suppress on the grounds that the records were obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment and that the Assistant District Attorney misused the grand jury subpoena process. The State appealed to the Seventh Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court’s suppression order because “[Huse] lacked standing to raise a Fourth Amendment challenge…and [because] the State did not acquire [Huse’s] medical records through an unlawful grand jury subpoena.” State v. Huse, No. 07-12-00383-CR, 2014 WL 931265 (Tex. App.—Amarillo Mar. 6, 2014). Huse filed a petition to the Court of Criminal Appeals for a discretionary review of his case.

The Two Big Issues for The Court of Criminal Appeals

The Court of Criminal Appeals set out to determine whether the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (“HIPAA”) impacts Fourth Amendment standing when the State obtains medical records in a criminal matter, and, whether the State acquired Huse’s records via a grand jury subpoena that potentially violated HIPAA.

The Fourth Amendment and Reasonable Expectation of Privacy

Under the Fourth Amendment, “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated.” U.S. CONST. amend. IV. “The provision protects people, not places.” Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347, 351 (1967). In order to raise a Fourth Amendment claim, a person must have legal standing, that may be “predicated on…a reasonable expectation of privacy principle.” United States v. Jones, 132 S.Ct. 945 (2012); Florida v. Jardines, 133 S.Ct. 1409 (2013).

State v. Hardy: The Precedent Case for the CCA

In Hardy, the CCA recognized that when the State itself extracts blood from a DWI suspect, and then subsequently conducts a blood alcohol analysis, then two “discrete searches” have occurred for a Fourth Amendment analysis. State v. Hardy, 963 S.W.2d 516 (Tex. Crim. App. 1997). The State neither extracted the sample nor conducted the blood alcohol analysis. As a result, the CCA concluded that the “Fourth Amendment does not apply to a search or seizure, even an arbitrary one, effected by a private party on its own initiative.” Skinner v. Railway Labor Exec. Assn., U.S. 602, 624 (1989). Further, “society [does not] recognize a reasonable expectation of privacy in privately-generated and maintained medical records that would show the result of a blood alcohol analysis [in a DWI investigation].” Hardy, 963 S.W.2d at 525-27.

The CCA Decides Whether HIPAA Trumps the Holding In Hardy?

Here, the CCA says that the State neither extracted nor analyzed Huse’s blood sample—the third-party hospital did. Huse, therefore, has no Fourth Amendment standing because he had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his privately-generated and maintained medical records. Further, “whatever interests society may have in safeguarding the privacy of medical records, [such interests] are not strong to require protection of blood-alcohol test results taken by hospital personnel solely for medical purposes after a traffic accident.” Id. But what about HIPAA? Does HIPAA trump the holding in Hardy?

The CCA explains that while HIPAA “might support a broader claim that society recognizes that patients have a legitimate expectation of privacy in their own medical records, generally, HIPAA does not undercut the Court’s holding in Hardy.” Further, the CCA states, “HIPAA expressly permits the disclosure of otherwise protected health information when it is sought by grand jury subpoena.”

In sum, Huse had no expectation of privacy in third-party generated and maintained medical records for a Fourth Amendment claim, and, no provisions in HIPAA specifically deny the disclosure of health information in the event of a criminal investigation. The CCA affirms the judgment Seventh Court of Appeals that Huse's medical records shall not be suppressed.

Read full article

Speak with a Fort Worth attorney

Call (817) 993-9249 or send us a message to discuss your case.