Short answer: An examining trial is a pre-indictment hearing in a Texas felony case where a magistrate decides whether there is enough evidence to hold the accused and sets or reviews bail. Under Article 16.01 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, anyone accused of a felony has the right to an examining trial before indictment, whether in jail or out on bond. That right ends when a grand jury returns an indictment, so the request has to be made early.

Most people arrested for a felony in Dallas-Fort Worth never hear the words "examining trial." The case moves from arrest to magistration to bond, and then everyone waits for a grand jury. But Texas law gives the accused a tool that can be used in that waiting period: a hearing where the State has to put on evidence, witnesses can be cross-examined under oath, and their testimony is recorded.
At Howard Lotspeich Alexander & Williams, PLLC (HLAW), our Fort Worth criminal defense lawyers represent people charged with felonies in Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, Johnson, and Parker counties. This guide explains what an examining trial is, when you can get one, how it works, and why the decision to request one is a strategic call.
Key Takeaways
- It is a felony right. "The accused in any felony case shall have the right to an examining trial before indictment in the county having jurisdiction of the offense, whether he be in custody or on bail" (Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 16.01).
- An indictment ends it. The right to an examining trial "is in fact terminated by the return of an indictment" (State ex rel. Holmes v. Salinas, Tex. Crim. App. 1990).
- It has three purposes. To decide whether there is sufficient evidence to hold the accused, to decide bail, and "to perpetuate the testimony of witnesses" (Salinas).
- Witnesses can be cross-examined. Defense counsel may question witnesses on direct or cross-examination, and the same rules of evidence apply as at a final trial (arts. 16.06, 16.07).
- Testimony is preserved. Each witness's testimony is reduced to writing or preserved in an approved statement of facts (art. 16.09).
- The judge must rule within 48 hours. Failure to enter an order within 48 hours "operates as a finding of no probable cause and the accused shall be discharged" (art. 16.17).
What Is an Examining Trial in Texas?
An examining trial is Texas's version of what many states call a preliminary hearing. It takes place before a magistrate, after an arrest or charge but before a grand jury has returned an indictment. Article 16.01 directs the magistrate to "examine into the truth of the accusation made, allowing the accused, however, sufficient time to procure counsel" (art. 16.01).
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has described the "traditional and statutory purposes" of an examining trial as: "(1) to determine whether there exists sufficient evidence of guilt to hold a suspect accused of criminal conduct; (2) to determine whether bail should be allowed and if so, the amount of bail; and (3) to perpetuate the testimony of witnesses, including any voluntary statement the suspect may wish to make" (State ex rel. Holmes v. Salinas).
The court also explained that while an examining trial "may be a practical tool for discovery by the defendant, the primary justification for its existence is to protect the innocent defendant from incarceration on a totally baseless accusation."
Who Has the Right to an Examining Trial?
The statutory right belongs to a person accused in a felony case. Key points:
- Felony charges only. Article 16.01 gives the right to "the accused in any felony case." Misdemeanor cases do not carry the same statutory right.
- In custody or on bond. The right applies "whether he be in custody or on bail."
- In the right county. The hearing takes place "in the county having jurisdiction of the offense."
- Before indictment. Once the grand jury returns an indictment, the right is gone.
- Juvenile transfers. If the accused was transferred from juvenile court for criminal prosecution after a hearing under Family Code § 54.02, an examining trial is available only "at the discretion of the court" (art. 16.01).
Article 16.01 also allows a magistrate, "in a proper case," to appoint counsel to represent the accused in the examining trial only.
When Does the Right to an Examining Trial End?
The right ends when the grand jury indicts. In Salinas, the Court of Criminal Appeals said that "although a suspect's right to an examining trial is termed 'absolute', it is very well settled that this right to a preliminary hearing is not unrestricted but is in fact terminated by the return of an indictment." It added that if "the grand jury returns a true bill prior to the time that an examining trial is held, the principal purpose and justification of such hearing has been satisfied."
Texas courts continue to apply that rule. In 2021, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals rejected a complaint that the trial court failed to hold an examining trial before indictment, stating that "a defendant's right to an examining trial is ended by the return of an indictment" (In re Hector, Tex. App.-Houston (14th Dist.) 2021).
Can the judge stop the prosecutor from going to the grand jury?
No. In Salinas, a judge granted examining trials and ordered the district attorney not to seek indictments until the hearings were held. The Court of Criminal Appeals held the judge "did not have the authority" to issue those orders, explaining that "the district attorney is entitled by statute to proceed, regardless whether an examining trial is pending, to seek an indictment in a criminal matter." The court also held that "due process considerations are not implicated" because a grand jury's probable cause determination is "at least as timely."
In practice, this means an examining trial is a race. If the defense wants one, the request should be made quickly, and the prosecutor may still choose to present the case to a grand jury first. Our guide to the Texas grand jury process explains what happens there.
What Happens at an Examining Trial?
Chapter 16 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets out the procedure.
- Warning to the accused. Before witnesses testify, the magistrate must tell the accused that he has the right to make a statement, that he "cannot be compelled to make any statement whatever," and that any statement "may be used in evidence against him" (art. 16.03).
- Optional voluntary statement. If the accused wants to make a statement, he may do so "before the examination of any witness, but not afterward." It is reduced to writing and signed, but not sworn (art. 16.04).
- Witness testimony. "The counsel for the State, and the accused or his counsel may question the witnesses on direct or cross examination" (art. 16.06).
- Rules of evidence. "The same rules of evidence shall apply to and govern a trial before an examining court that apply to and govern a final trial" (art. 16.07).
- Recording the testimony. Testimony is reduced to writing and signed, or preserved in a statement of facts authenticated by both sides and approved by the magistrate (art. 16.09).
- Postponements. Either side may ask to postpone the examination to obtain testimony (art. 16.02).
- Decision. The judge must order the accused committed to jail, discharged, or admitted to bail "as the law and facts of the case may require" (art. 16.17).
The 48-hour rule
Article 16.17 contains a firm deadline: "Failure of the judge to make or enter an order within 48 hours after the examining trial has been completed operates as a finding of no probable cause and the accused shall be discharged" (art. 16.17).
Examining Trial vs. Grand Jury vs. Probable Cause Affidavit
Several early-stage steps in a Texas felony case involve probable cause, and they are easy to confuse.
| Step | Who decides | Is the accused present? | Can the defense cross-examine? | What it decides |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Probable cause affidavit / magistration | Magistrate, based on paperwork | Usually yes, for warnings and bail | No | Whether the arrest or warrant was supported, and initial bail |
| Examining trial | Magistrate, after a hearing | Yes | Yes (art. 16.06) | Whether there is enough evidence to hold the accused, and bail |
| Grand jury | Grand jurors, in a secret proceeding | No, unless invited | No | Whether to indict (true bill) or not (no bill) |
If the problem is the warrant affidavit itself, other tools may apply. Our article on challenging probable cause affidavits and Franks hearings covers that issue.
Why Would a Defense Lawyer Request an Examining Trial?
The decision depends on the case. Reasons a defense lawyer may consider one include:
- Locking in testimony early. A complaining witness or officer testifies under oath, on the record, before stories have time to change. That record can be used to test consistency later.
- Seeing the State's case. The court in Salinas recognized that an examining trial "may be a practical tool for discovery by the defendant." Formal discovery rights are discussed in our guide to the Michael Morton Act.
- Challenging weak cases. If the evidence does not support holding the accused, the magistrate may discharge him.
- Revisiting bail. The magistrate "shall determine the amount or sufficiency of bail, if a bailable case" (art. 16.01). For more on bond, see our Fort Worth bail bonds guide.
Reasons to be cautious
An examining trial is not always the right move:
- Testimony is preserved for both sides. The same recorded testimony that helps the defense can also become part of the record the State uses later.
- The accused's statement can be used. Article 16.03 warns that any statement "may be used in evidence against him." Most defendants should not make one.
- It can prompt faster action. A request may lead the prosecutor to present the case to the grand jury sooner, which ends the right.
- It may educate the State's witnesses. Cross-examination can reveal defense theories before trial.
These tradeoffs are why the decision should be made with counsel who knows the facts and the local practice in the county where the case is pending.
What if You Are Sitting in Jail Waiting for an Indictment?
An examining trial is one tool, but it is not the only protection against long pretrial detention. Article 17.151 of the Code of Criminal Procedure generally requires a detained defendant to be released on personal bond or reduced bail if the State is not ready for trial within 90 days of the start of detention in a felony case, subject to statutory exceptions (Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 17.151). Whether that rule applies depends on the charge and the circumstances, so talk with a lawyer about both options.
If you have learned there is a warrant for your arrest but have not been picked up yet, our guide on what to do about an outstanding warrant in DFW explains the next steps.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an examining trial the same as a preliminary hearing?
Yes, in substance. The Court of Criminal Appeals in Salinas referred to the examining trial as a "preliminary hearing" under Article 16.01. Texas uses the term "examining trial" in the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Can I get an examining trial for a misdemeanor?
Article 16.01 gives the right to an examining trial to "the accused in any felony case." Misdemeanor cases do not carry the same statutory right.
Can I still get an examining trial after I am indicted?
No. Texas courts consistently hold that the return of an indictment ends the right to an examining trial.
Do I have to testify at an examining trial?
No. The magistrate must tell you that you cannot be compelled to make any statement and that anything you say may be used against you. If you choose to make a statement, it must come before any witness testifies.
Can my lawyer cross-examine the officer?
Yes. Article 16.06 allows the accused or his counsel to question witnesses on direct or cross-examination, and Article 16.07 applies the same rules of evidence as at a final trial.
What happens if the judge does not rule?
If the judge does not make or enter an order within 48 hours after the examining trial is completed, Article 16.17 treats that as a finding of no probable cause, and the accused must be discharged.
Does an examining trial stop the grand jury?
No. The Court of Criminal Appeals has held that the district attorney may seek an indictment regardless of whether an examining trial is pending.
Talk With a Fort Worth Criminal Defense Lawyer
The window to request an examining trial can close quickly, and whether to use it is a judgment call that depends on the facts. If you or a family member has been arrested for a felony anywhere in Dallas-Fort Worth, HLAW can review the charge, the bond, and the early options with you. Call (817) 993-9249 or contact us online for a free consultation.
This article provides general information about Texas law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its specific facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Laws change, so consult a licensed Texas attorney about your situation.



